One pie shop on this list turns out 30 to 40 different homemade pies every single day. That is not a typo, and it is not a holiday special.
Another spot sells its pies from a food trailer with no dining room at all. A different bakery even has a drive-through, which feels like a direct challenge to your self-control.
I laughed out loud at the idea of a burger joint calling itself a fried pie shop first. Then I got curious about the pies, and the burgers had to wait.
Arkansas takes its crust seriously, from mountain general stores to tiny Main Street cafes. Picking just one slice here feels like choosing a favorite child.
1. Rymolene’s Pies
Decision fatigue is real when a pie case holds 30 to 40 different homemade pies on a single day. Welcome to the happiest problem in Fayetteville.
Rymolene’s Pies is a charming bakery that puts pie front and center. You’ll find a long lineup of sweet slices, plus sandwiches for anyone who insists on lunch first.
The flavors lean playful without losing their homemade heart. Look for names like coconut-banana cream, Arizona Sunshine lemon, and Cherry Berry.
Some choices land on the unusual side, which is half the fun. The crust stays tender and flaky, so the filling never has to carry the slice alone.
Here’s a smart move for first-timers. Order two or three slices to share, then compare notes like a pie judge at the county fair.
Coffee comes free with your visit, which feels like a friendly nudge to linger. Free Wi-Fi helps too, in case you need to text friends about your pie choices.
Vegetarians get a nice surprise on the savory side. A vegetarian Sloppy Joe sits on the menu, proving this shop thinks beyond dessert.
The shop welcomes everyone and offers a gender-neutral restroom. A free parking lot makes popping in for one more slice dangerously easy.
Timing matters if you want a calmer visit. Mornings tend to run quieter, while Tuesday afternoons and Saturday evenings bring the crowds.
Hours stretch into the evening most days, which is great news for after-dinner cravings. Sunday hours are shorter, so plan your Sunday pie run early.
Address: 955 N Shiloh Dr, Fayetteville, AR 72701
2. Charlotte’s
Southern Living once called the coconut meringue pie here the best anywhere, back in 2011. Keo is a tiny town, but that is a giant compliment.
Charlotte’s sits on Main Street and serves homemade pies with classic sandwiches. The setting feels historic and casual, the kind of place built for lunch with friends.
The chocolate pie is a must-try, made from scratch and voted the best for years. Caramel pie also gets attention for being made fresh.
Strawberry pie shows up as a menu highlight too. Picking just one flavor might be the hardest part of your day.
Lunch is the only window here, so pay close attention. Charlotte’s opens 11 AM to 2 PM, Tuesday through Saturday.
That short schedule makes this a planned trip, not a random stop. Many pie fans would call that drive a worthy mission.
The food beyond dessert gets praise for quality, like perfectly ripe avocado. A full vegetarian menu means more people at your table can join the fun.
Groups and families fit in easily, with high chairs for little ones. Reservations are accepted, and a private dining room works for bigger gatherings.
Catering is available for anyone who wants Charlotte’s pies at a party. Your guests may start asking where you’ve been hiding this talent.
Parking is free and usually plentiful, both in the lot and on the street. Small-town perks like that make the trip feel easy.
Address: 290 Main St, Keo, AR 72083
3. The Wooden Spoon
Meatloaf, catfish, and chocolate peanut butter pie walk into a restaurant in Gentry. The punchline is a very satisfied lunch crowd.
The Wooden Spoon specializes in home-style cooking and homemade pies. It sits inside a beautiful historic building, complete with a fireplace and a gift shop.
Chocolate peanut butter pie is the slice to know. Pair it with the catfish dinner if you want the full comfort food lineup.
Mama’s Meatloaf shows up on the menu, along with a meatloaf sandwich. Baked potato soup and chicken salad sandwiches also earn plenty of love.
Save room, though, because the pie is why you came. Splitting an entree and ordering two slices is a very reasonable strategy.
The staff keeps the mood friendly and courteous. That hometown kindness makes the whole meal feel like dinner at a relative’s house.
Lunch runs 10:30 AM to 2 PM, Monday through Saturday. Dinner service joins on Friday and Saturday evenings from 5 to 8 PM.
Friday evenings get the busiest, and there’s usually a wait. Reservations aren’t accepted, so arrive with patience and an appetite for small talk.
Kids are welcome, with high chairs and a kids’ menu on hand. A full vegetarian menu also helps mixed groups find something easy.
Browse the gift shop while you wait for a table. Just don’t buy so many trinkets that you forget the pie.
Address: 1000 S Gentry Blvd, Gentry, AR 72734
4. Morrison’s Fried Pies
No tables, no restroom, no problem. Morrison’s Fried Pies runs from a food trailer in Hot Springs, and the pies do all the talking.
Every order here is to go. That makes these handheld pies perfect for a drive, a park bench, or your car’s cupholder.
The menu covers both sweet and savory fried pies. Meat pies and fruit pies share the spotlight, so breakfast and dessert can happen at once.
Pecan stands out as a menu highlight. It packs classic Southern pie flavor into a portable pocket you can eat with one hand.
The crust is the real headline. It turns out flaky and light, and it isn’t greasy, which is impressive for anything fried.
Fillings taste fresh, and the fruit versions bring bold flavor. Grab one savory and one sweet so you can test both sides.
Doors open early, at 8 AM Tuesday through Saturday. Weekday hours run until 5 PM, while Saturday wraps up at 3 PM.
Saturday mornings bring the biggest rush. Weekday mornings and afternoons stay calmer, which helps if you hate lines.
The friendly staff keeps things moving quickly. Expect a short stop, then a long, happy drive full of crumbs.
Prices stay gentle on your wallet, making it easy to buy a few extra. Your future self, staring at an empty fridge tonight, will be grateful.
Address: 1333 Albert Pike Rd, Hot Springs, AR 71913
5. The Fried Pie Shop (Burgers, Pies, & Fries)
Spinach and mushroom inside a fried pie? Jacksonville’s favorite pie stop isn’t afraid to get creative with its crust.
The Fried Pie Shop pairs premium brisket burgers with its signature fried pies. Burgers might share the name, but pies clearly run the show.
These fried pies come in giant sizes, perfectly crusted and filled. The shop proudly carries a fried pie tradition going back over 100 years.
Chocolate pie and peaches and cream pie are popular picks. The spinach and mushroom version gives savory fans a real reason to cheer.
Free bite-sized samples can help you decide. Accepting one is basically research, and research is important.
Frozen fried pies are also on the menu. Take a few home and enjoy that crispy crust on a lazy weeknight.
Burgers use real beef, and the fries come well seasoned. Chili cheese fries make a strong case for skipping the salad today.
The Fried Pie Shop in Jacksonville opens at 10 AM daily and closes at 8 PM, according to its current online ordering schedule.
Friday and Saturday evenings get the busiest, while mornings stay quiet.
You’ve got options for how you eat. Drive-through, dine-in, takeout, and delivery all work here.
Families will find high chairs and a kids’ menu. Dogs can join you outside, so the whole crew gets a road trip treat.
Address: 1321 T P White Dr, Jacksonville, AR 72076
6. Oark General Store
Getting to Oark feels like driving into the middle of nowhere. Then a slice of apple caramel crumb pie appears, and suddenly nowhere feels perfect.
Oark General Store is a historic Ozark Mountain eatery inside an old gas and grocery store. The setting alone makes the scenic drive worth it.
Homemade pies headline the menu next to signature burgers. Coconut cream and peanut butter pie both get rave-worthy attention.
Apple crumb is another favorite, especially served a la mode. Ice cream on warm crumb topping is a mountain tradition you should respect.
Burgers and sandwiches fill out the savory side. A bacon cheeseburger stands as a highlight, so lunch and dessert are both covered.
Breakfast starts at 8 AM, and the doors close at 4 PM. The store closes on Tuesdays, so plan your Ozark loop carefully.
Weekends bring the biggest crowds, especially Saturday and Sunday mornings. Weekday mornings run quieter if you want a relaxed slice.
Inside, a fireplace adds old-time charm on chilly days. Outside, a pet-friendly dining pavilion welcomes your four-legged travel buddy.
Reservations aren’t accepted, so just show up hungry. Kids have their own menu and high chairs for little diners.
Fill up your appetite before the trip, not your snack bag. You’ll want every bit of room for at least two slices.
Address: 117 Co Rd 5241, Oark, AR 72852
7. Blue Cake Honey Pies at Bowman
Key lime pie in Little Rock might not sound like a local tradition. One forkful at Blue Cake Honey Pies could change your mind fast.
This specialized bakery makes scratch-made pies alongside custom celebration cakes. It’s an artisan pie shop with a calm, quiet seating area.
The key lime pie earns big praise for being sweet, tangy, and smooth. A great crust holds it together like a dependable best friend.
Apple pie arrives with a crumb topping and apples cooked just right. Fans of crunchy toppings will feel completely at home.
Great coffee makes it easy to settle at a table with your slice. Free Wi-Fi turns a quick pie break into a productive afternoon.
Service runs friendly and quick. That’s handy if you’re grabbing a whole pie for a dinner party at the last minute.
Need a cake too? Custom celebration cakes mean birthdays and pie cravings can be handled in one stop.
Delivery is available, along with in-store pickup. Shopping inside works too if you like picking your pie in person.
Hours run 10 AM to 6 PM on weekdays. Saturday closes at 4 PM, and Sunday is a day off.
Free parking in the lot and on the street keeps things simple. Your only real challenge is deciding between tangy and crumbly.
Address: 315 N Bowman Rd #14, Little Rock, AR 72211
8. Route 62 General Store
Shopping for gifts and walking out with pie is the best kind of distraction. Route 62 General Store in Eureka Springs makes that happen often.
This charming roadside store mixes homemade soups and sandwiches with fresh baked desserts. Unique gifts fill the shelves, so browsing comes with the meal.
Pies are freshly made in-house every day. That daily baking keeps the dessert case worth checking each time you pass by.
Strawberry rhubarb pie is a top favorite. Its sweet and tart mix makes a great match for a lazy Ozark afternoon.
Chocolate cream pie also wins big praise. If you love smooth, rich slices, this one belongs on your plate.
Lunch fans should try the chicken salad sandwich on a croissant. It pairs nicely with a slice for a light meal that still feels like a treat.
Hours run 10 AM to 3 PM, Tuesday through Saturday. Mondays and Sundays are closed, so plan your Eureka Springs trip with that in mind.
In-store pickup is available for easy grab-and-go orders. Delivery isn’t offered, so come by in person.
Parking is free, with an on-site lot and street spaces. That’s a nice break in a town known for winding hills.
Visiting Arkansas mountain towns already tempts you with scenery. This stop adds pie to the list, and your diet never stood a chance.
Address: 2080 E Van Buren, Eureka Springs, AR 72632
9. Piehouse Bakery
A pie shop with a drive-through sounds like a dare to your self-control. Bentonville’s Piehouse Bakery offers exactly that, and nobody has to know.
Scratch-made pies are the main event here. Sweet and savory pastries round out the case, so breakfast becomes a real option.
Apple and strawberry pies show up as menu highlights. Peanut butter and sour cherry also earn serious love from families who return again and again.
That sour cherry pie deserves your attention if you like a little tang. It balances sweet and tart in a way that keeps you reaching for another forkful.
Now for the crust, which seems built for road trips. It holds up for days in the fridge and even survives cooler travel to another state.
Think about that next time you visit Arkansas from out of town. A whole pie could ride home with you and still taste like itself.
Doors open at 7 AM Tuesday through Saturday. Pie with morning coffee counts as breakfast here, and we support that decision.
The bakery closes at 3 PM, so late sleepers need a plan. Saturday mornings bring the biggest crowds, while Tuesday mornings stay calmer.
Free Wi-Fi and a gender-neutral restroom make stopping in simple. A free parking lot helps if you choose to skip the drive-through.
Monday and Sunday are off days for this crew. Mark your calendar so you don’t pull up to locked doors with a hungry car.
Address: 310 S Walton Blvd, Bentonville, AR 72712