This Maine Donut Shop Makes Its Famously Moist Donuts With Real Mashed Potatoes In The Dough

Eliza Thornton 9 min read
This Maine Donut Shop Makes Its Famously Moist Donuts With Real Mashed Potatoes In The Dough

There’s a potato in your donut. A real mashed Maine russet, to be exact. Before you question the recipe, consider this: the bakery now makes roughly 1.7 to 1.9 million donuts a year.

The idea started around 2011, when a friend suggested adding potatoes to a homemade recipe. In an apartment kitchen. With no indication that this little suggestion would eventually require producing millions of donuts.

And the flavors? Dark chocolate sea salt, sweet potato ginger, and even one inspired by Maine’s official state treat, the whoopie pie.

That last one raises a question. If you’re eating a donut inspired by a whoopie pie, are you technically having two desserts?

The shops sometimes sell out before closing, so don’t leave your visit too late.

I’d especially like to hear the conversation when someone first offered guests a mashed potato donut. How many people said yes without asking a single question?

Real Russet Potatoes Are The Secret You Can Actually Taste

Real Russet Potatoes Are The Secret You Can Actually Taste
© The Holy Donut

Mashed potatoes belong next to meatloaf, right? The Holy Donut disagrees, and its first shop in Portland, Maine has been proving the point since 2012.

The shop’s signature potato donuts are made with real Maine russet potatoes worked straight into the dough.

That choice changes the whole donut. The potatoes add steady moisture and richness, so the donuts stay soft instead of drying out fast. They come out more substantial than a fluffy yeast ring and denser than a basic cake donut.

Fresh ones have a soft interior and a lightly crisp outside. Think of it as a donut with a little more backbone. You won’t mistake one for an airy gas-station glazed, and that’s the whole point.

Here’s a tip for first-timers. Because the texture is heavier, one donut can feel like a real snack rather than a quick bite. Splitting a few flavors with a friend lets you sample more without tapping out early.

The potato itself doesn’t shout. It works quietly in the background, like a great bass player. What you notice is the moist, rich crumb that keeps pulling you back for another bite.

Credit the humble spud for that, and maybe thank Maine farmers too.

A Kitchen Experiment Grew Into A Family Business

A Kitchen Experiment Grew Into A Family Business
© The Holy Donut

Leigh Kellis never set out to build a donut empire. Around 2011, the single mother started testing donut recipes in her apartment kitchen. She wanted something delicious and more wholesome than the usual options.

Then a friend tossed out a strange idea. Why not add potatoes? That suggestion turned into the signature move behind The Holy Donut, and the first shop opened in Portland in 2012.

Family showed up from the start. Her father Allan, mother Cynthia, sister Elizabeth, and brother-in-law Jeff Buckwalter all pitched in as the business grew. Buckwalter is now a co-owner and the CEO.

That homegrown story matters when you bite into one. These donuts didn’t come from a corporate test lab or a focus group. They came from a home cook chasing a better treat and listening to a friend’s odd advice.

Remember that the next time a pal suggests something weird in the kitchen. Sometimes the wild idea is the good one. In this case, it led to a shop that now makes close to two million donuts a year.

Not bad for leftover-sounding spuds.

Start With The Bestseller And Work Outward From There

Start With The Bestseller And Work Outward From There
© The Holy Donut

Dark Chocolate Sea Salt holds the crown as the top seller. It’s made with high-quality dark chocolate, including Belgian Callebaut, and finished with a salty sprinkle. Sweet, salty, and rich all at once.

From there, the menu fans out in fun directions. Over 20 flavors rotate through, with seasonal choices joining the classics. Pure Vanilla Glazed and Chai Glazed cover the comfort side of things.

Craving something brighter? Lemon and Pomegranate bring a fruity zip. Sweet Potato Ginger uses sweet potatoes the shop roasts itself, which feels fitting for a place already devoted to potatoes.

Coffee Cake and Chocolate Coconut round out more of the lineup. Maple Bacon sits in its own category of breakfast-meets-dessert. One bite delivers pancake vibes without the syrup-sticky table.

A smart plan is to grab one familiar flavor and one adventure. That way you have a baseline and a surprise. Glazes get their color from real fruits and vegetable coloring, so the bright pinks and purples come from honest sources.

Good luck choosing just two.

Maine Blueberries Make A Very Local Case For Glaze

Maine Blueberries Make A Very Local Case For Glaze
© The Holy Donut

Blueberries and Maine go together like lighthouses and fog. So it makes perfect sense that the Blueberry Glazed donut uses Maine blueberries. Local fruit on top of local potatoes is a pretty tidy story.

The shop’s ingredient list leans local in other ways too. Butter and buttermilk come from local sources, and the flour is unbleached. Everything gets made from scratch daily.

Each donut is rolled and cut by hand before frying and finishing. That’s a lot of hands-on work for something that disappears in a few bites. It also explains why the shop can sell out.

For visitors, the blueberry donut works as an edible postcard. You get a taste of the state without hunting down a farm stand. Pair it with a walk around Portland and you’ve built a tiny Maine food tour.

One friendly suggestion is to buy a spare. Blueberry fans rarely stop at one, and the drive home suddenly feels much shorter with backup. Your future self will thank you around the second traffic light.

Cannoli Filling And Whoopie Pie Tributes Live Here

Cannoli Filling And Whoopie Pie Tributes Live Here
© The Holy Donut

Some donuts just aren’t content being donuts.

The Holy Cannoli features a donut topped with sweet ricotta filling and a flavorful glaze.

It’s Italian bakery energy with a Maine potato twist.

Then there’s the Whoopie Pie donut. Whoopie pies are the official state treat of Maine, so this one is basically a delicious history lesson. Two famous treats team up in one package.

Here’s a handy tip if you order ahead. Cannoli-style donuts feature a ricotta topping, so check your order before leaving. A cannoli without cream is just a sad tube.

These creative options show the shop’s sense of fun. The potato dough acts like a canvas, and the bakers keep painting new ideas on it. That playful streak keeps repeat trips interesting.

If you’re bringing a group, grab one of each to share. Cut them into pieces and pass them around. Everyone gets to vote on a favorite, and somebody always ends up defending the whoopie pie with surprising passion.

Savory Fans Get Bacon, Cheddar, And Breakfast Options Too

Savory Fans Get Bacon, Cheddar, And Breakfast Options Too
© The Holy Donut

Not everyone wants sugar at seven in the morning. Good news for the savory crowd. The Holy Donut makes donuts stuffed with bacon and cheddar.

Picture a breakfast sandwich and a donut meeting halfway. The potato dough already has a hearty feel, so it handles salty fillings well. It reads more like a meal than a dessert.

The shop also offers savory breakfast options, including hash browns.

They give you a way to grab real breakfast before diving into the sweet stuff. Balance, sort of.

This is a smart move for mixed groups. One person can go full glaze while another sticks to cheese and bacon. Nobody leaves grumpy or hungry.

Try a savory option first, then follow it with a sweet donut as a chaser. The contrast makes the sweet one taste even brighter. It’s the same logic as salty fries before a milkshake.

Savory choices can move quickly, so earlier is better. Morning shoppers have the widest pick. Show up late and you might be stuck admiring the empty tray.

Gluten-Free And Vegan Eaters Are Invited To The Party

Gluten-Free And Vegan Eaters Are Invited To The Party
© The Holy Donut

Food allergies can make bakery trips feel like a letdown.

The shop offers dietary alternatives, although people with food allergies still need to consider cross-contact risks.

That’s a big deal for families with mixed diets.

Many visitors with different dietary preferences can find options at the same counter.

Vegan options help folks avoiding dairy, which can be tricky with donuts. Gluten-free choices open the door for people who usually skip wheat-based pastries altogether. Both come with the same creative spirit as the regular lineup.

A practical tip is to ask what’s available that day. Flavors rotate, and specialty options can sell out like everything else. Going earlier gives you a better shot at the full selection.

It’s also worth reading labels carefully if you have serious allergies. Talk with staff about your needs before ordering.

Staff can explain the available options and potential allergen cross-contact risks before you order.

Inclusive menus like this one make a shop feel welcoming. Nobody has to watch from the sidelines.

More visitors can enjoy a donut that suits their dietary preferences, and that seems like the way the world should work.

The Original Park Avenue Shop Is Where It All Began

The Original Park Avenue Shop Is Where It All Began
© The Holy Donut

History buffs, take note. The shop at 194 Park Avenue, Portland, ME 04102 was the very first Holy Donut location. Everything else grew from this spot.

Today the brand also runs a Commercial Street shop in Portland, plus a location in Scarborough.

The Park Avenue shop sits away from the busy waterfront. That can make it a handy choice if you’re on that side of town.

Hours run from 6:30 AM to 2:00 PM every day of the week. That’s a morning-and-lunch window, so plan accordingly. Late sleepers may need an alarm.

Here’s the bigger catch. Shops often close early when they sell out. Arriving before noon gives you the best selection by far.

Coffee is on hand too, including organic coffee from Wicked Joe. Iced coffee gets made with frozen coffee cubes, so it doesn’t turn watery as the ice melts. Smart thinking for a hot summer day in Maine.

Grab a cup, pick a box, and you’re set.