The sauce goes on top. The cheese hides underneath, stacked in a thick layer over a buttery crust.
That upside-down order is classic Chicago deep-dish, and one spot in Louisiana builds it the authentic way. Each pie is made to order. That means at least 45 minutes before it reaches your table.
The same kitchen also turns out New York thin crust, so two rival pizza cities share one menu. I like how the place treats that rivalry as a friendly debate instead of picking a side.
There’s even local ice cream waiting for dessert. Which camp will you join, the thick slice or the foldable one?
Good Things Take 45 Minutes, So Plan Ahead

Fast food this is not. Every deep-dish pie at That’s Amore Pizzeria needs at least 45 minutes to bake.
That number surprises some first-timers. However, a pizza this thick simply can’t be rushed. The crust needs time to turn golden, and all that cheese needs time to melt through.
Here’s the smart move. The restaurant lets you pre-order your deep-dish ahead of time. That way, your pie can be close to ready when you show up.
Hungry families will thank you for this tip. Nobody enjoys watching the clock with a growling stomach.
If you do dine in without ordering ahead, plan around the wait. Grab an appetizer, chat with your table, and let the anticipation build.
I can’t imagine a better excuse to slow down for dinner. The wait becomes part of the experience. It’s a little like waiting for a birthday cake to come out of the oven.
Thin crust takes less time, of course. So if someone in your group refuses to wait, they can order New York style. Everyone still eats together, and nobody gets cranky.
Two Veterans Brought Chicago And New York To The Same Table

That’s Amore Pizzeria is at 4441 West Metairie Avenue in Metairie, Louisiana, west of New Orleans. Follow West Metairie Avenue through the neighborhood’s commercial corridor.
The restaurant has a street-facing location along West Metairie rather than a downtown New Orleans address. Look for the pizzeria at the marked building and do not confuse it with its New York-style menu offerings.
Use lawful nearby parking and head into the storefront. Allow additional time for Chicago-style deep dish, which the restaurant says takes more than forty-five minutes to bake.
Cheese On The Bottom, Sauce On Top, And No Apologies

Flip your pizza expectations upside down. At this kitchen, the chunky tomato sauce lands on top, right where Chicago tradition puts it.
Underneath sits the good stuff. A buttery crust holds generous layers of cheese and toppings, built tall like a savory cake.
Why the strange order? Deep-dish pies bake a long time. Putting sauce on top helps protect the cheese below during that long trip through the oven.
The result looks impressive the moment it arrives. You’ll probably want a fork and knife for this one. Picking up a slice with your hands is brave, but maybe not wise.
Toppings tuck between the cheese and the sauce, so every bite brings a little of everything. Fans of a supreme or a meat-heavy pie will find plenty to explore on the menu.
I believe this style changes how people think about pizza night. It feels more like a hearty dinner than a quick snack. One slice can go a long way.
Louisiana has plenty of famous food. Still, few places here make a pie that stands this tall and proud.
Pick Your Size, From Personal Pie To Party Pan

Size matters when your pizza is this thick. Luckily, the deep-dish comes in three options, so you can match the pie to your crowd.
The smallest is a 7-inch pie. Don’t let that number fool your math, though. A deep-dish packs far more filling than a flat pizza of the same width.
Next up is a 13×9-inch rectangle. That’s the same shape as a classic baking pan, which feels fitting for something this hearty.
For bigger groups, there’s a 14-inch round. It’s the choice for family dinners, team parties, or anyone who loves leftovers.
So how do you choose? Think about appetites and sides. If you’re adding appetizers, a smaller pie might be plenty.
Leftovers are a happy bonus here. A slice of deep-dish can make a satisfying lunch the next day.
I like that the menu gives this much flexibility. Solo diners aren’t stuck with a giant pie, and big groups aren’t stuck sharing a tiny one. Everyone gets a fair shot at that layered cheese.
Just remember the 45-minute bake time applies to every size.
Team Thin Crust Gets Its Moment Too

Not everyone wants a pizza they need a knife for. New York thin crust fans, this one’s for you.
That’s Amore Pizzeria treats the thin crust as a full partner in the great debate. It isn’t a backup plan. It’s the other half of the restaurant’s whole identity.
New York style is the opposite of Chicago in almost every way. The crust is thin, the slices are wide, and the sauce sits under the cheese.
Many people fold their slices lengthwise, New York style. It’s practical, and it also makes you feel like you’re standing on a busy city sidewalk.
Thin crust also arrives faster than deep-dish. That makes it handy for quick lunches or picky kids who want food right now.
Here’s a fun idea for a group visit. Order one of each style and run your own taste test. Score them on crust, sauce, and cheese.
I believe this is the best way to experience the place. You get the full story instead of half of it. Then the arguing can begin, with full mouths and friendly opinions.
Pasta And Po’boys Are Hiding On This Menu

Plenty of pizzerias stop at pizza. This one keeps going, and Louisiana flavor shows up in a big way.
Homemade pasta plays a starring role. Lasagna, Alfredo, and spaghetti are on the menu, and each comes with a salad and a breadstick.
Then come the po’boys. You can choose fillings like shrimp, catfish, oyster, or mahi mahi. Each one is available grilled or fried.
That mix is pure Metairie. An Italian-American pizzeria serving a proper po’boy makes perfect sense in this part of the country.
The menu also includes sandwiches, seafood, and chicken dishes. Appetizers and salads round things out nicely.
This variety solves a common family problem. Maybe one person craves pizza while another wants seafood. Here, nobody has to compromise or eat somewhere else later.
I like how this menu respects where the restaurant lives. It brings Chicago and New York to town without forgetting about Louisiana.
Good luck choosing just one thing. You might need to plan a second visit. Maybe a third, if the fried catfish calls your name.
Save Room For Creole Creamery Scoops

Bananas foster ice cream after deep-dish pizza? That’s a combination worth clearing your schedule for.
The restaurant has an in-house ice cream station serving flavors from Creole Creamery, a New Orleans-area favorite. Bananas foster and creole cream cheese are among the flavors offered.
Creole cream cheese might sound unusual to visitors. It’s a tangy local tradition, and it tastes like a true taste of the region.
Bananas foster is another New Orleans classic. Turning it into ice cream makes it easy to enjoy without any fancy tableside show.
Classic desserts are available too. Tiramisu and cheesecake sit on the menu, along with cookies.
So the meal can end Italian style or Louisiana style. Kids will likely head straight for the ice cream, and honestly, that’s a fair choice.
I believe the ice cream station is one of the sweetest surprises here. It connects a Chicago-inspired pizza place to its local roots in a fun way.
Planning tip: save a little space. After a slice of deep-dish, that might take real willpower. Still, a cold scoop after hot cheese is hard to beat.
Gluten-Free Friends Don’t Have To Sit This One Out

Pizza nights can feel tricky for anyone avoiding gluten. Thankfully, this menu doesn’t leave those diners staring at a plain salad.
That’s Amore Pizzeria offers gluten-free cauliflower crust pizza. Several other gluten-free menu items are available as well.
That matters for mixed groups. One friend’s dietary needs shouldn’t decide where everyone eats dinner.
Cauliflower crust is a popular choice for people who still want the fun of pizza. You can pile on toppings and share in the moment with everyone else.
If you have a serious allergy, it’s smart to ask about preparation before ordering. A busy pizza kitchen handles lots of flour, so clear communication always helps.
Accessibility goes beyond the menu, too. The restaurant has an accessible entrance, which makes visits easier for guests using wheelchairs or strollers.
I like when a restaurant thinks about everyone who might walk through its doors. Small choices like these make a big difference to families.
The great debate is more fun when the whole table can join. With these options, nobody is stuck on the sidelines. Everyone gets a vote, and everyone gets a slice.
Find It On West Metairie Avenue, Six Days A Week

Finding Chicago deep-dish in south Louisiana is easier than you’d think. That’s Amore Pizzeria sits at 4441 West Metairie Avenue, Metairie, Louisiana 70001.
Free parking makes the trip simple. That’s a welcome perk anywhere near New Orleans, where parking can test anyone’s patience.
The restaurant is also near major shopping centers. So you can run errands, then reward yourself with a cheesy pie.
Getting your food is flexible. You can dine in, pick up your order, or get delivery.
Hours are worth noting before you go. The doors open at 11 a.m. Tuesday through Sunday. Closing is 8 p.m. most nights and 9 p.m. on Friday and Saturday.
Mondays are the day off. Many hungry people have learned that lesson the hard way, so mark it on your calendar.
Remember that 45-minute deep-dish bake when choosing your arrival time. Late arrivals near closing may want to order ahead.
I can’t imagine a better Louisiana stop for a pizza argument. Thick or thin, folded or forked, the debate is waiting. All you need to bring is an opinion.