TRAVELMAG

This Secret Florida Craft Store Is Tucked Inside A Forgotten Church

Aaron Mitchell 10 min read
This Secret Florida Craft Store Is Tucked Inside A Forgotten Church

The oldest church building in its county now sells paintings, pendants, and garden planters. Yes, really.

The pews gave way to local art, and every sale helps keep the old walls standing.

The building went up in 1895, the same year its town changed names. Its steeple came down sometime between 1915 and 1920.

The current owners hope to put it back someday.

I love that a couple bought this place in 2019 just to save it. I can’t imagine a more charming way to shop for a gift in Florida.

You browse original art while standing inside real pioneer history.

The doors only open three afternoons a week, though. So what exactly waits inside this little white church, and why do people keep ringing the bell?

A Pioneer Church That Now Answers To Art Lovers

A Pioneer Church That Now Answers To Art Lovers
© The 1895 Church of StuArt

The 1895 Church of StuArt might be the only shop in town where the building is older than the town’s current name. That’s a fun twist for a place that sells brand-new art.

Today, the old church works as a fine art studio and gallery. It’s also known as the Olga Hamilton Fine Art Studio and Gallery.

Inside, you’ll find original paintings, drawings, and ceramic sculptures. There are also limited edition printed reproductions and fine art photography.

The mix doesn’t stop at wall art, either. Small gifts, garden decor, kitchen decor, planters, pendants, and medallions fill out the collection.

Most of the work comes from local artists. So every piece has a hometown connection, which makes gift shopping feel a lot more personal.

The best part is where your money goes. Proceeds from art sales help pay for the upkeep and preservation of the historic building.

That means a single small purchase does double duty. You get something lovely, and an old Florida landmark gets a little stronger.

Honestly, that beats grabbing another candle at the mall. Your gift comes with a story, and the story comes with a steeple fund.

The Oldest Church Building Around Has Quite A Résumé

The Oldest Church Building Around Has Quite A Résumé
© The 1895 Church of StuArt,311 SW 3rd Street, Stuart, FL 34994

Back in 1895, settlers of a tiny place called Potsdam built a church. That same year, Potsdam was renamed Stuart.

The First Methodist Church built the structure and dedicated it in June 1895. It now holds the title of oldest church building in what is today Martin County.

Plenty changed over the following decades. The steeple was removed sometime between 1915 and 1920, which left the building a bit shorter.

Then came another chapter. In 1932, the building was dedicated and renamed St. Mary’s Episcopal Church.

Think of it as a building that keeps reinventing itself without losing its bones. Pioneer church, Episcopal church, and now art gallery is a pretty impressive career path.

The state has taken notice too. The property is listed in the Florida Master Site File as a historical cultural resource.

In December 2023, the Florida Division of Historical Resources said it appears to meet National Register criteria. That’s a big deal for a modest wooden church.

So when you visit, you’re standing in more than a shop. You’re standing in the earliest days of a Florida town finding its name.

Take The Tour Before You Start Shopping

Take The Tour Before You Start Shopping
© The 1895 Church of StuArt,311 SW 3rd Street, Stuart, FL 34994

Art is the reason many folks stop by, but the building tour might steal the show. Visitors can take a tour to learn the history of the church itself.

The owners, Robert W. Hamilton Jr. and Olga Hamilton, know this building well.

They bought it in June 2019 with one clear goal.

That goal is preservation. They want to keep this piece of Stuart history standing and cared for.

A tour helps the art make more sense too. Once you know the backstory, every painting on those old walls feels like part of a bigger story.

Got a history buff in the family? Bring them along and watch them light up over the Potsdam connection.

Kids can get something out of it too. It’s not every day you learn that a whole town changed its name the year a church opened.

Ask questions while you’re there. The owners love sharing the details, and the building has over a century of them to give.

After the tour, browsing feels different. You’ll likely look at that pendant or planter and think about the old church it helps support.

Look Up, Look Around, And Spot The Original 1895 Siding

Look Up, Look Around, And Spot The Original 1895 Siding
© The 1895 Church of StuArt,311 SW 3rd Street, Stuart, FL 34994

Old buildings love to hide clues, and this one is no exception. Inside, the original 1895 gable lap siding survives in the section where the steeple once stood.

That’s a small detail with a big payoff. You’re looking at wood that settlers nailed up well over a century ago.

Speaking of wood, portions of the building are made of Dade County pine. This tough lumber is famous for its strength and its staying power.

The beadboard walls and ceilings are getting some love right now. They’re being restored and painted white, which brightens the whole space.

Don’t miss the windows. The lancet windows have that classic pointed shape you’d expect in an old church.

Their trim is planned to be stained, so the look keeps evolving. Each visit might reveal a little more restoration progress.

I like how the building feels like a work in progress, just like the art inside. Nothing about it is frozen in a glass case.

Take a slow lap before you browse. The architecture is a gallery piece all on its own, and it doesn’t come with a price tag.

So Many Mediums, So Little Wall Space At Home

So Many Mediums, So Little Wall Space At Home
© The 1895 Church of StuArt,311 SW 3rd Street, Stuart, FL 34994

Acrylics, oil pastels, soft pastels, and watercolors all share the walls here. That’s just the start of the list.

You’ll also spot India ink, colored pencils, mixed media, and digital art. Every artist brings a different tool kit.

The subjects vary just as much. Some pieces glow with nature-inspired light, while others lean whimsical and abstract.

Then there are the deeper works. A few pieces explore more philosophical ideas, the kind that make you stop and stare for a minute.

And yes, there’s even wearable art. That’s a fun option if your walls are already packed.

This variety makes the gallery great for picky gift shoppers. A watercolor lover and an abstract fan can both leave happy.

Here’s a practical tip. Snap a quick photo of the wall at home where you want to hang something before you go.

It makes choosing size and color much easier. Your living room deserves a little Florida sunshine, even if it comes in ink.

Plus, original art from local hands feels special. You won’t find the same piece hanging in your neighbor’s house.

Little Treasures Make Great Last-Minute Gifts

Little Treasures Make Great Last-Minute Gifts
© The 1895 Church of StuArt,311 SW 3rd Street, Stuart, FL 34994

Not every gift needs a frame. The gallery also offers small art gifts that fit easily in a bag.

Pendants and medallions are part of the mix. They make thoughtful presents for birthdays, teachers, or that friend who has everything.

Garden lovers get options too. Planters and garden decor bring a bit of artistic flair to a porch or patio.

Kitchen decor rounds things out. A creative touch near the stove can make cooking dinner feel a little less like a chore.

These smaller items are handy when you’re short on time. Pop in, pick something, and you’re the hero of the party.

They also make great souvenirs. Visiting the Treasure Coast?

A piece from a historic Florida church beats a plastic keychain any day.

Gifts from local artists come with a story you can share. Tell the person it helped preserve a building from 1895, and watch their eyebrows go up.

Keep a short list of birthdays in your phone before visiting. You might knock out three presents in one stop and support history while you’re at it.

Want Something Custom? The Owners Can Point You To An Artist

Want Something Custom? The Owners Can Point You To An Artist
© The 1895 Church of StuArt

Maybe you love a style but need a different size. Or perhaps you want a painting of your own dog lounging on the beach.

Good news. The owners can connect you with local artists for custom commissions.

That opens up all kinds of ideas. A family home, a favorite fishing spot, or a beloved pet could become a one-of-a-kind piece.

Classes are on the table too. The Hamiltons can help arrange art classes with local artists.

This is perfect for anyone who’s always wanted to try watercolors. It also works for kids who doodle on every scrap of paper in the house.

Olga Hamilton is a fine artist and photographer herself. So the people helping you understand the creative process from the inside.

Bring a few reference photos if you’re thinking about a commission. Clear pictures make it easier to share your vision.

Also, think about timing. Custom work takes effort, so asking early is smart if you have a special date in mind.

Either way, you leave with more than a purchase. You leave with a new creative connection in Stuart.

Plan Around These Weekend-Only Hours

Plan Around These Weekend-Only Hours
© The 1895 Church of StuArt,311 SW 3rd Street, Stuart, FL 34994

Timing matters with this one. The 1895 Church of StuArt is open Friday, Saturday, and Sunday from noon until 5 PM.

That makes it an easy weekend outing. Sleep in, grab lunch, then head over for an afternoon of art and history.

You’ll find it at 311 SW 3rd Street, Stuart, FL 34994. It sits right in Downtown Stuart, Florida.

The downtown location is a big plus. You can pair your visit with a stroll around the area afterward.

Give yourself enough time, though. Between the tour and the art, an hour can slip away fast.

Arriving earlier in the afternoon helps. You won’t feel rushed as closing time creeps closer.

Weekday visitors may need to adjust plans. Midweek trips to Stuart work best if you can stretch them into a Friday.

Write the hours down or save them in your phone. Nothing stings like showing up on a Tuesday to a locked door and a lovely view of the windows.

Once you’ve got the timing right, the rest is simple. Just bring curiosity and maybe a little extra room in the car.

Help A Missing Steeple Find Its Way Home

Help A Missing Steeple Find Its Way Home
© The 1895 Church of StuArt,311 SW 3rd Street, Stuart, FL 34994

Every old building has a wish list. This one wants its steeple back.

Restoring the steeple is part of the owners’ ongoing mission. It was removed over a century ago, sometime between 1915 and 1920.

Bringing it back would return the church closer to its original 1895 look. That’s an exciting goal for anyone who loves Florida history.

So how can regular folks help? The simplest way is buying art, since sales directly support maintenance and preservation.

Showing up matters too. Visiting, taking the tour, and spreading the word all keep this landmark in the spotlight.

The Hamiltons also share updates and gatherings on Facebook. Following along is an easy way to catch upcoming art and get-together events.

I believe places like this survive because people care enough to stop by. A handful of curious visitors can make a real difference.

The 1895 Church of StuArt has already outlasted name changes, a lost steeple, and new congregations. With a little help, its next chapter could be the best one yet.

Picture the photos once that steeple returns. You’ll want to say you were part of it.