TRAVELMAG

This Michigan Steakhouse Pairs Sizzling Steaks And Seafood With A Speakeasy Atmosphere

Hailey Pratt 9 min read
Gatsby's Seafood & Steakhouse
This Michigan Steakhouse Pairs Sizzling Steaks And Seafood With A Speakeasy Atmosphere

A steakhouse famous for hand-cut beef also runs a full vegan night every single Wednesday. That combo alone made me stop scrolling. I can’t think of many surf-and-turf spots that bother with a scratch-made vegan menu.

The room adds its own twist. Brick walls, Tiffany-style lamps, and jazz instruments give the place a Roaring Twenties speakeasy look. A fireplace keeps the mood warm when Michigan weather turns rude.

Then there’s the food lineup. Flounder stuffed with crabmeat dressing and topped with lobster sauce sits on the same menu as a sizzling Black Angus steak.

One family has run this downtown spot for more than two decades. What keeps a 1920s-style dining room feeling this fresh after all these years?

Crabmeat Stuffing And Lobster Sauce Make Flounder Feel Fancy

Crabmeat Stuffing And Lobster Sauce Make Flounder Feel Fancy
© Crabmeat Stuffing And Lobster Sauce Make Flounder Feel Fancy

Flounder Del Ray might be the most dramatic plate on the seafood side. It comes stuffed with crabmeat dressing and topped with lobster sauce.

That’s seafood on seafood on seafood. Honestly, it sounds like a dish that refuses to do anything halfway.

Fresh fish gets hand-cut daily here, just like the beef. That care shows up across a long list of choices.

Salmon fans get two very different paths. Ginger Glazed Salmon brings a sweeter angle, while Salmon New Orleans arrives Cajun rubbed with grilled shrimp.

Swordfish and an Ahi Tuna Steak cover the meatier side of the ocean. Parmesan Whitefish offers a nod to a Great Lakes favorite.

Craving something classic? Fish N Chips features lightly battered cod, and a Shrimp Dinner keeps things simple.

House-recipe crab cakes also show up on the menu. They work as a starter or a centerpiece, depending on your mood.

This lineup makes Gatsby’s Seafood & Steakhouse a smart pick for mixed groups. Half the table can chase steak while the other half sails off toward fish.

Everybody wins, and nobody has to compromise.

The Roaring Twenties Never Really Left This Brick-Walled Room

The Roaring Twenties Never Really Left This Brick-Walled Room
© The Roaring Twenties Never Really Left This Brick-Walled Room

Gatsby’s Seafood & Steakhouse is at 203 Center Avenue in downtown Bay City, Michigan. Approach the commercial district near the Saginaw River via Center Avenue.

Wenonah Park and the riverfront are useful orientation points near the western end of Center Avenue. The restaurant sits among the historic downtown storefronts.

Find legal downtown parking and finish on foot at the Center Avenue entrance.

Steak Lovers Get A Hand-Cut Reason To Show Up Hungry

Steak Lovers Get A Hand-Cut Reason To Show Up Hungry
© Steak Lovers Get A Hand-Cut Reason To Show Up Hungry

Superior 1855 beef anchors the steak side of this menu. The kitchen hand-cuts it daily, aiming for tenderness and flavor in every order.

The Black Angus sizzler steak is the one that matches the title of this story. A steak that arrives sizzling has a way of announcing itself before you even see it.

Want something bigger? A 16-ounce New York strip sits on the menu for serious appetites.

Then there’s the signature Bronx Sirloin Steak. Any dish called a signature deserves at least one careful look.

Entrees typically come with a house salad and your choice of side. That makes the plate feel complete without extra planning.

Picking that side might be the hardest decision of the night. Options include a twice baked potato, maple sweet mashed potato, and mashed potatoes with gravy.

Grilled vegetables and steak cut fries also make the list. Hand cut sweet potato fries round out the potato-heavy lineup nicely.

My advice is simple. Choose your steak first, then let the side become your fun little reward.

Just don’t spend so long deciding that your table starts feeling restless.

Wednesday Belongs To The Vegan Chef, And That’s A Big Deal

Wednesday Belongs To The Vegan Chef, And That's A Big Deal
© Wednesday Belongs To The Vegan Chef, And That’s A Big Deal

Most steakhouses toss vegans a sad side salad and call it a day. Gatsby’s went a completely different direction.

The restaurant offers a comprehensive vegan menu made from scratch. It’s not an afterthought tucked at the bottom of a page.

Every Wednesday brings Vegan Night. That’s when the vegan chef rolls out off-menu features you won’t find the rest of the week.

Some regular vegan options include a Vegan Salad and a vegan fish sandwich. There’s even a vegan gyro, which sounds like a fun surprise at a surf-and-turf spot.

I love what this means for mixed groups. A steak fan and a plant-based eater can share one table without anyone feeling left out.

Vegetarian choices and comfort food also appear on the menu. The variety makes planning a group dinner much easier.

Wednesday becomes the clear choice for curious eaters. You get regular favorites plus those special chef features in one visit.

Bring a friend who swears they could never enjoy a vegan meal. A cozy speakeasy room might just change their mind.

Worst case, they order the sizzler and everyone stays happy anyway.

Escargot, Calamari, Or Dip? The Starter List Makes You Choose

Escargot, Calamari, Or Dip? The Starter List Makes You Choose
© Gatsby’s Seafood & Steakhouse

Escargot shows up on the starter menu, right next to Cheese Stix. That range tells you plenty about the personality of this kitchen.

The appetizer list covers a lot of ground. Bruschetta and Spinach and Artichoke Dip handle the cheesy, shareable side of things.

Calamari arrives as lightly breaded strips. It’s an easy pick when the table can’t agree on anything else.

Seafood fans have even more options to consider. Crab Stuffed Shrimp, Smoked Salmon Dip, and crab cakes all make an appearance.

Smoked Wings bring a heartier option. Ahi Tuna and Portobello Mushrooms add a couple of lighter, earthier choices.

Here’s my practical tip. Order one or two starters for the whole table instead of one each.

Entrees already come with a salad and a side. Saving a bit of room is a smart move, not a sign of weakness.

Sharing also turns the start of the meal into a little tasting tour. You get to sample more without committing too hard.

And yes, someone will probably fight over the last bite of dip. Consider that part of the fun.

Burgers, Wraps, And Lunch Plans Worth Stretching Out

Burgers, Wraps, And Lunch Plans Worth Stretching Out
© Burgers, Wraps, And Lunch Plans Worth Stretching Out

Lunch here starts at 11:30 AM on most weekdays and Saturdays. That opens the door for a midday break with serious options.

The sandwich list goes well beyond basic. Choices include the Buster Burger, Bacon Blue Burger, and The Works Burger.

Chicken lovers can go for the Pretzel Chicken. The Traverse City Chicken Wrap gives a fun Michigan shout-out right in its name.

The Gatsby Philly carries the house name, so it practically begs for a try. A Whitefish Sandwich and Shrimp Tacos keep the seafood theme alive at lunch.

Pair any of them with Pub Chips or Hand Cut Sweet Potato Fries. Coleslaw works too if you want something crisp and cool.

Mondays bring Burger Monday, with a discount on any burger. Note that Monday hours start later, with the doors opening at 4 PM.

That makes Monday dinner a great burger night. It’s a nice way to soften the start of the week.

I like that a speakeasy setting doesn’t demand a fancy order. A good burger in a moody brick room feels like a small treat.

Sometimes that’s exactly what a long day needs.

Save Room, Because A Chocolate Turtle Lava Is Waiting

Save Room, Because A Chocolate Turtle Lava Is Waiting
© Save Room, Because A Chocolate Turtle Lava Is Waiting

Chocolate Turtle Lava. Those three words should be enough to make you rethink finishing every last fry.

This dessert stands out as the decadent pick on the menu. The name alone suggests chocolate and turtle-style flavors in one rich package.

So how do you plan for it? Strategy matters at a place where entrees already come with a salad and a side.

One smart approach is sharing. Split a starter, enjoy your main course, and leave space for something sweet.

Another option is takeout. Gatsby’s offers takeout service, so a boxed treat for later isn’t out of the question.

Dessert also feels right in this setting. A dim, jazz-themed room with a warm fireplace practically calls for a slow finish.

I believe the best dinners end without a rush. Lingering over something chocolate fits that idea perfectly.

Celebrating a birthday or anniversary? A shared dessert makes the moment feel a little more official.

Even on a plain Tuesday, it works as a reward for surviving the week so far. No special occasion required, just a fork and good timing.

Four Generations Of Restaurant Know-How Run Through This Kitchen

Four Generations Of Restaurant Know-How Run Through This Kitchen
© Four Generations Of Restaurant Know-How Run Through This Kitchen

Rick and Kyle Revette opened this restaurant in 2001 in downtown Bay City. Their family brings four generations of restaurant experience to the table.

That’s a lot of history behind one dinner menu. It helps explain why the place balances classic steakhouse fare with fresh ideas like a vegan night.

You’ll find Gatsby’s Seafood & Steakhouse at 203 Center Avenue, Bay City, Michigan 48708. The restaurant sits inside a historic building, which suits the vintage theme beautifully.

Bay City itself goes way back. The community was established in 1837 and became a city in 1865.

So a Twenties-style dining room fits right into an older downtown. The setting and the story feel connected rather than forced.

Getting there is easy too. Free lot and street parking are available, which removes one common downtown headache.

Inside, Wi-Fi is provided for anyone who needs it. Still, I’d suggest keeping the phone in your pocket for most of the meal.

A family-run spot with this much staying power earns a little attention. More than two decades in, the Revette touch still shapes the experience.

A Little Planning Goes A Long Way Before You Head Over

A Little Planning Goes A Long Way Before You Head Over
© A Little Planning Goes A Long Way Before You Head Over

Sundays are off the table, literally. The restaurant stays closed that day, so plan your visit for Monday through Saturday.

Hours shift a bit during the week. Monday runs 4 PM to 9 PM, while Tuesday through Thursday go from 11:30 AM to 9 PM.

Fridays and Saturdays stretch until 10 PM. Those later nights give you more room for a relaxed dinner.

Reservations are accepted, especially for parties of eight or more. Walk-ins are welcome too, which keeps spontaneous plans possible.

Bigger group? Calling ahead is the smart move, since seating for large parties benefits from a heads-up.

Warm Michigan evenings bring another option. Outdoor patio seating lets you enjoy downtown air with your meal.

Families can come along comfortably. A children’s menu and high chairs are available, and the restaurant welcomes both groups and solo diners.

Accessibility gets solid attention here. Wheelchair-accessible entrances, seating, and restrooms help more people enjoy the visit.

Put it all together, and Gatsby’s Seafood & Steakhouse makes planning pretty painless. Pick your night, choose patio or fireplace, and let the Twenties do the rest.