Mustard ice cream? Yep, a sandwich shop in Colorado Springs actually serves it. And somehow, that’s not even the most interesting thing on the menu.
The same spot makes a Thanksgiving sandwich, and it’s not alone. In Colorado, delis are stuffing turkey, cranberry, and all the holiday favorites between two slices of bread.
Who needs November?
I might prefer this to the actual Thanksgiving dinner. No dishes, no hours of cooking, and no waiting all afternoon for the turkey to be ready.
Just all the good stuff in between two slices of bread.
From mountain towns to city streets and stops near famous red rocks, these sandwich shops are bringing Thanksgiving to the lunch counter.
The only thing missing is your uncle asking why you’re still single.
1. Capriotti’s Sandwich Shop
A sandwich called The Bobbie sounds like a friendly neighbor, and honestly, it acts like one. It shows up with turkey, stuffing, cranberry sauce, and mayo on toasted sub bread.
That combo is the whole point of a stop here. You get the flavors of a holiday plate without waiting until the fourth Thursday of November.
Capriotti’s is a counter-service deli chain known for hearty signature subs. The Colorado Springs shop on East Cheyenne Road gives you a casual spot to grab one before the holiday rush.
Not feeling turkey today? The menu also includes the Chicken Chipotle Crunch, a Grilled Italian, and an American Wagyu French Dip.
Cheesesteak fans have options too. There’s a Cheesesteak BLT, plus Cheesesteak Fries for anyone who believes fries deserve toppings.
Families should feel right at home. The shop has a kids’ menu, high chairs, and a Kids Grilled Cheese Meal for picky eaters.
Hours run long, which helps during a busy November week. The shop opens at 9 AM Monday through Saturday and 10 AM on Sunday, closing at 8:30 PM Monday through Saturday and 8 PM on Sunday.
Short on time? Takeout and delivery are both available, and there’s outdoor seating if the weather cooperates.
Here’s a smart move for pre-Thanksgiving errands. Grab a Bobbie for lunch, and you’ll shop for groceries without that hungry, grab-everything feeling.
Parking shouldn’t slow you down, since the free lot usually has plenty of space. That means more time for eating and less time circling.
Address: 140 E Cheyenne Rd Suite 110, Colorado Springs, CO 80906
2. Yampa Sandwich Company
Ski boots and stuffing make a better pair than you’d guess. In Steamboat Springs, the Pilgrim sandwich delivers turkey, stuffing, and cranberry sauce on a roll.
Yampa Sandwich Company sits right on Lincoln Avenue, the main drag through town. It’s a local deli chain serving gourmet sandwiches in a casual, trendy setting.
Early risers get a head start here. The shop opens at 8 AM daily, closing at 7 PM Monday through Saturday and 5 PM on Sunday, with breakfast and lunch options available.
That makes it handy for road trips over the holiday week. You can grab coffee and a breakfast sandwich, then circle back later for the Pilgrim.
Gluten-free diners, take note. The deli offers gluten-free bread, and staff use separate preparation for guests with celiac disease.
The menu has plenty beyond turkey. Look for a Pastrami Reuben, Italian Beef, a Cuban, a Turkey and Cheddar Melt, and vegan soups.
Bringing your pup along for the drive? Dogs are allowed in the outdoor seating area, so your furry copilot can join lunch.
Timing matters in a busy mountain town. Mornings during the week and Saturday afternoons tend to fill up, while Monday evenings are quieter.
Parking can get tricky on Lincoln Avenue. Free lot and street spaces exist, but finding one may take a little patience.
Visiting Colorado’s ski country before Thanksgiving gives you snow, scenery, and an early holiday meal in one stop. That’s a pretty great trade for a sandwich.
Address: 635 Lincoln Ave, Steamboat Springs, CO 80487
3. Yampa Sandwich Co.
Cranberry chutney sounds fancy, but it belongs on a sandwich. At this Denver deli, it joins roasted turkey and stuffing in a warm Thanksgiving-style creation.
The sauce doesn’t drown the bread, either. You get a balanced layer of chutney, so the turkey and stuffing still shine.
You’ll find this Yampa Sandwich Co. on Wazee Street in LoDo. It’s a cute little spot with seating inside and out.
Breakfast starts at 8 AM daily, and the doors stay open until 8 PM. That works nicely for downtown workers and visitors alike.
The menu brings big flavors beyond the holiday lineup. Check out the Pork Carnitas Torta, the Pastrami Reuben, or a build-your-own pastrami sandwich.
Got a sweet tooth after lunch? An Ice Cream Sandwich waits on the dessert side.
Families can relax here too. There’s a kids’ menu, and the mood stays casual and quiet.
Weekday afternoons get the biggest crowds. Weekends and evenings tend to be calmer, so plan around that if you hate waiting.
Downtown parking is the tough part. Spots are paid and often hard to find, so curbside pickup or delivery can save you a headache.
Picking up lunch before a holiday shopping trip in downtown Denver? This stop gives you a taste of the feast in a much smaller package.
Address: 1617 Wazee St, Denver, CO 80202
4. Dish Gourmet
A Thanksgiving dinner tucked inside a warm ciabatta sandwich sounds like the perfect excuse to stop in Boulder. At Dish Gourmet, the Thanksgiving sandwich brings natural turkey, cranberry, stuffing, and gravy together in one satisfying handheld meal.
That gravy makes all the difference. Instead of just stacking turkey and cranberry between slices of bread, this sandwich brings the rich, comforting flavors of a traditional holiday plate into every bite.
You’ll find Dish Gourmet on Pearl Street, where this locally owned sandwich shop has built a reputation for creative combinations and carefully prepared ingredients.
The kitchen takes its meat seriously. Slow-roasted deli meats are a major part of the operation, giving the sandwiches a homemade touch that fits the restaurant’s relaxed personality.
Not craving Thanksgiving flavors? The Gobbler offers another turkey option, combining natural turkey with avocado, Muenster cheese, bacon, tomato, lettuce, and pesto mayo on ciabatta.
The menu stretches well beyond turkey, too. The Italian brings together several cured meats, fresh mozzarella, roasted tomatoes, and a balsamic olive spread on a baguette.
Vegetarian diners have options as well, and the shop offers house-made gluten-free bread for anyone looking for an alternative to traditional sandwich rolls.
Every sandwich comes with potato chips and a pickle. It’s a classic deli combination that makes grabbing a complete lunch simple.
Plan your visit around the daytime schedule. Dish Gourmet opens from 9 AM to 3 PM Monday through Saturday and closes on Sundays, so it’s best suited for a late breakfast or lunch stop.
If you’re exploring Boulder before Thanksgiving, this is an easy place to grab an early taste of the holiday. Turkey, stuffing, cranberry, and gravy are already waiting between the bread, and you won’t have a roasting pan to wash afterward.
Address: 1918 Pearl St, Boulder, CO 80302
5. Colonel Mustard’s Sandwich Emporium
Mustard ice cream exists, and you can order it in Colorado Springs. The Colonel’s Mustard Ice Cream is just one quirky reason to visit this shop.
The real holiday star is the Thanksgiving sandwich. It pairs roasted turkey with classic holiday fixings and tastes a lot like home.
Colonel Mustard’s Sandwich Emporium leans into its mustard theme with premium ingredients. The menu is huge, and the portions are generous.
Then there’s the patio. From the outdoor seats, you can see Garden of the Gods and Pikes Peak on a sunny day.
That view might be the best side dish in Colorado. Pair it with a turkey sandwich, and lunch suddenly feels like a mini vacation.
Hungry for something different? The Sgt Pepper and Colonel Hero are popular picks.
Pastrami on Swirled Rye, a Quartermaster Hot Dog, and Lobster Mac and Cheese also show up. Vegans and vegetarians each get a full menu.
Hours run from 9 AM to 4 PM daily, so plan this as a breakfast or lunch stop. Service is quick, which helps on a busy day.
Friday and Saturday afternoons draw the biggest crowds. Monday is the quietest time to grab a seat.
Bring the dog for the patio, and park for free on-site. A turkey sandwich, a mountain view, and mustard ice cream make a mighty fine pre-holiday plan.
Address: 1412 21st St, Colorado Springs, CO 80904
6. Joe’s Famous Deli
Thanksgiving dinner tastes even better when mountain scenery comes with it. At Joe’s Famous Deli in Vail, the Turkey Day sandwich brings roasted turkey, mushroom stuffing, cranberry, and mayo together in one hearty handheld meal.
That mushroom stuffing gives this sandwich its own personality. Instead of simply recreating the traditional holiday plate, it adds an earthy twist that pairs nicely with the sweet cranberry.
You’ll find Joe’s on Bridge Street, right in the heart of Vail Village. It’s a convenient place to stop while exploring the shops or taking a break from the chilly mountain air.
The menu offers plenty of alternatives if someone in your group isn’t craving Thanksgiving flavors. The Rosemary Chicken combines chicken, avocado, feta, red onion, cabbage, and Dijon spread.
Roast beef fans can go for the sandwich with Swiss cheese, fresh tomato, cabbage, mayo, and horseradish sauce. There’s also an Italian sandwich loaded with several cured meats and provolone.
Bread choices give you room to customize. Sourdough, French baguette, rye, and even a gluten-free option are available, so you can build your sandwich to suit your appetite.
Visiting before Thanksgiving makes the Turkey Day especially appealing. You get all those familiar holiday flavors without spending hours preparing a feast.
Grab your sandwich and enjoy a little mountain-town atmosphere. Between the crisp air and the cranberry-stuffed turkey creation, Joe’s makes a satisfying Colorado stop.
Address: 288 Bridge St, Vail, CO 81657
7. Home Team Deli
Baseball and Thanksgiving dinner don’t usually share the same lineup, but Home Team Deli in Broomfield makes the combination work. Its sandwich, called The Ted, brings oven-roasted turkey, cranberry sauce, stuffing, and gravy together on grilled sourdough.
That grilled bread is an important part of the experience. It gives the soft stuffing and gravy a sturdy foundation while adding a little crunch to every bite.
The restaurant leans heavily into baseball culture, with sandwiches named after famous players and familiar moments from the sport. The Ted fits right into that playful naming system.
You’ll find the deli on West 120th Avenue in Broomfield. It’s a convenient suburban stop for anyone running errands or looking for a satisfying lunch before the holiday rush.
The menu stretches well beyond Thanksgiving flavors. The Big Papi pairs turkey and pepperoni with provolone, banana peppers, black olives, lettuce, and tomato on Italian bread.
Another option is the Say Hey Club, which brings together ham, turkey, bacon, cheddar, tomato, and ranch mayo on toasted sourdough.
Sandwich lovers who prefer something meat-free have choices too. The menu includes vegetarian options alongside the stacked meat sandwiches.
The Ted is the natural pick if you’re craving an early Thanksgiving dinner. Turkey, stuffing, cranberry, and gravy make it feel like the holiday has arrived ahead of schedule.
Consider it a warm-up for the real feast. No carving knife, no complicated seating arrangements, and no mountain of dishes afterward.
Address: 5160 W 120th Ave, Unit G, Broomfield, CO 80021
8. Half Fast Subs On The Hill
A Thanksgiving dinner tucked into a toasted sub sounds like exactly the kind of idea a college-town sandwich shop would dream up. Half Fast Subs in Boulder makes it happen with a creation called the Gobbler.
Turkey, stuffing, gravy, and cranberry sauce all get packed into the bread. It’s the familiar holiday combination, only this time you can eat it without balancing several dishes on your lap.
The Gobbler belongs to the shop’s Stuffed Subs lineup. That’s where traditional sandwich rules get tossed aside in favor of hearty combinations inspired by full meals.
Another option is the Stuffed Turkey, which trades cranberry and stuffing for garlic mashed potatoes and gravy. It’s a different way to enjoy comfort food between two slices of bread.
You’ll find Half Fast Subs on 13th Street in Boulder’s University Hill neighborhood. The area brings plenty of student energy, making the shop a lively stop during a day of exploring town.
The menu is famously extensive, with more than a hundred sandwich combinations to consider. Pastrami, roast beef, chicken, vegetarian options, and creative turkey subs all compete for attention.
For something completely different, the Albuquerque Turkey combines turkey with jalapeños, green chile, Fritos, pepper jack, bacon, and sriracha aioli.
But if Thanksgiving is the goal, the Gobbler keeps things wonderfully simple. The gravy adds richness, the cranberry brings sweetness, and the stuffing ties everything together.
Stop by before the holiday and treat it like a preview of the big meal. You’ll get the flavors of Thanksgiving without needing to loosen your belt for an entire afternoon.
Address: 1215 13th St, Boulder, CO 80302
9. Pat’s Philly Steaks & Subs
A shop famous for Philly-style sandwiches might not be the first place you’d expect to find Thanksgiving dinner. Pat’s Philly Steaks & Subs in Denver has a surprise waiting, though, and it goes by the name P.J. Gobbler.
This sandwich combines oven-roasted turkey, cranberry sauce, homemade stuffing, and mayo. It’s essentially a Thanksgiving plate tucked into a sub roll, with the option to order it hot.
That last detail makes a difference on a cold Colorado day. Warm turkey and stuffing bring the comfort, while cranberry sauce adds the familiar sweet-tart flavor that makes holiday leftovers so irresistible.
You’ll find Pat’s on East Iliff Avenue in Denver. It’s a casual stop when you’re craving a filling sandwich without the formality of a sit-down holiday meal.
Of course, Philly-style cheesesteaks remain a major part of the menu. The classic version combines grilled steak with melted white American cheese and your choice of toppings.
For something with a Colorado twist, the Green Chile Philly adds Hatch green chile to the steak-and-cheese combination. It’s a spicy alternative to the Thanksgiving flavors.
Turkey fans have more than one option too. The Danny Boy Club Sub combines oven-roasted turkey with ham, Swiss cheese, bacon, lettuce, tomato, and mayo.
The menu also includes the Pat Astrami, a grilled pastrami sandwich with Swiss cheese, homemade coleslaw, and Thousand Island dressing.
Still, the P.J. Gobbler is the one to order if you’re building a pre-Thanksgiving sandwich tour. You get the holiday’s greatest hits in one easy meal.
Pick it up for lunch between errands, or take it home for an early taste of the feast. Either way, Pat’s gives Denver another reason to celebrate turkey season.
Address: 7419 E Iliff Ave, Denver, CO 80231