One Michigan pie shop with a serious reputation keeps regular hours on just two mornings a week.
Its founder is a James Beard Award finalist. So when the doors open on Friday and Saturday, the crowd shows up ready.
Then there’s a bakery that builds nearly its whole menu around sweet potatoes. Pie, waffles, and even cheesecake get the treatment. That’s commitment on a whole new level.
Holiday orders here move fast. Lock yours in before relatives start handing out side dish assignments. Losing your seat at the grown-up table stings, but losing your pie slot hurts more.
Will you confess the pie came from a bakery, or let your family think you’ve been practicing all year?
1. Sister Pie
Short hours, big reputation. This Detroit bakeshop opens its doors on Friday and Saturday mornings, so timing matters more than usual.
Sister Pie opened its Detroit storefront in April 2015, and founder Lisa Ludwinski later became a James Beard Award finalist.
The shop focuses on creative sweet and savory pies made with local, seasonal ingredients.
For Thanksgiving 2026, the preorder lineup featured Salted Maple, Cranberry Crumble, and Spiced Chocolate Pecan. That trio covers sweet, tart, and chocolatey in one tidy package.
Salted Maple is the signature pie here. If you only grab one, that is the obvious place to start.
Missed the preorder window? A limited number of extra pies, cookies, hand pies, muffins, and scones go out first-come, first-served on November 25 and Thanksgiving Day.
Limited is the key word there. Showing up early beats showing up hopeful.
Outside the holiday rush, the regular menu leans playful. You might spot a Buckwheat Chocolate Chip cookie, a savory hand pie, assorted cookies, or blueberry pie.
Coffee is on hand too, which helps when you arrive right at opening. Wi-fi is available if you want to linger for a minute.
Here’s the practical advice. Sister Pie’s Thanksgiving 2026 preorders sold out on October 28, but there’s still a chance to grab a pie.
A limited number of extras will be available on November 25 and 26, first-come, first-served.
Treat it like concert tickets for dessert. Your Thanksgiving table will thank you for the planning.
Address: 8066 Kercheval Ave, Detroit, MI 48214
2. Grand Traverse Pie Company
Cherry pie from a company born near Michigan’s cherry country, now baked close to the Lake Michigan shoreline. Norton Shores scored a good deal here.
Grand Traverse Pie Company bakes more than 40 pie varieties. Michigan Montmorency cherry pies are a big part of its identity.
The Norton Shores shop serves sweet and savory pies plus classic cafe fare. Breakfast, lunch, and dinner are all on the table.
Chicken pot pie is a menu highlight. So are cherry pie, coconut pie, and apple crumble.
Need something besides pie? Cinnamon rolls, muffins, and cheesecakes come by the slice or whole.
For Thanksgiving, plenty of families make this an annual order. Pumpkin pies are a common pick for holiday pickup.
The company’s wider lineup includes Pecan and Apple Crumb with Pecans and Caramel. A no-sugar-added East Bay Natural Apple Pie is also part of the family menu.
Bringing kids along? There’s a kids’ menu, high chairs, and outdoor seating when the weather cooperates.
Parking is usually plentiful, with a free lot and street spots. That’s a gift during holiday errand season.
Afternoons on Tuesday, Wednesday, Friday, and Saturday tend to be the busiest. Evenings run quieter if you’re grabbing a slice.
Place your order ahead and skip the guessing game. A pot pie for the tired cook is optional but strongly encouraged.
Address: 5817 Harvey St, Norton Shores, MI 49444
3. Rosie’s Pies And Bakery
Lemon meringue with tall, fluffy peaks tends to steal attention from turkey. Rosie’s in Kawkawlin seems perfectly fine with that.
Rosie’s Pies and Bakery specializes in homemade pies. It also runs a full-service catering business, which is handy in November.
The lemon meringue gets attention for its buttery, flaky crust and bright zest. The meringue lands light yet thick.
Strawberry rhubarb is the other star. Sweet and tart together make it a nice break from heavy holiday desserts.
Here’s a bonus most pie shops can’t offer. The catering side handles Thanksgiving-style dishes too.
That means one stop could cover dessert and some of the meal. Your stovetop gets a well-earned breather.
Prices land on the reasonable side, which matters when you’re feeding a crowd. Big families notice that kind of thing.
Plan around the schedule. Rosie’s is open Tuesday through Sunday from 9 a.m. to 5 p.m. and is closed most Mondays.
Delivery and takeout are both options. A free parking lot keeps pickup simple on busy days.
Holiday demand around the Bay City area pushes people to order in advance. Waiting until the last minute is a risky game.
Call your pie shot early and pick your favorites. Lemon meringue on a Thanksgiving table is a small, sunny rebellion.
Address: 1142 S Huron Rd, Kawkawlin, MI 48631
4. Achatz Handmade Pie Co
Lobster pot pie and unstuffed cabbage soup sharing a menu with cherry crumb? That’s the kind of range you get at this Oxford pie shop.
Achatz Handmade Pie Co specializes in fruit pies and savory pot pies. Homemade soups and other comfort foods round out the counter.
The signature Michigan 4-Berry pie mixes tart cherries, blackberries, blueberries, and raspberries. A traditional crumb topping finishes it off.
Classic fans have plenty to choose from too. Dutch apple, pecan, and coconut cream all show up in the lineup.
Want something less expected? A Cannoli Cream Pie slice and a Chocolate Fudge Cake bring a little dessert-shop fun.
The cherry crumb features a crunchy topping of brown sugar, cinnamon, butter, and rolled oats, making it a treat for cherry pie lovers.
Thanksgiving here works best with a preorder. Pies can be picked up the day of, freshly made, which beats a pie that sat around all week.
Plan your days carefully, though. The Oxford shop is closed on Saturdays and open Sunday through Friday.
Delivery is available if your kitchen schedule is already packed. Takeout and in-store pickup make the counter stop quick.
A pot pie for Wednesday dinner is a sneaky smart move. Nobody wants to cook the night before the big feast.
Order early, grab a soup while you’re there, and let the berries do the talking. Michigan fruit rarely needs a hype team.
Address: 960 N Lapeer Rd, Oxford, MI 48371
5. Woodland Farm Market & Bakery
Apple fritters get top billing here, which is a bold move for a place packed with pies. Somehow it works.
Woodland Farm Market & Bakery in Shelby pairs a quaint market with a bakery. Scratch-made pies are what it’s famous for.
Cherry pie is a menu highlight, and that fits West Michigan nicely. Blueberry crumble and cherry streusel are also in the mix.
The shelves don’t stop at pie. Breads, large cookies, and donuts keep the basket filling up fast.
Those signature apple fritters deserve a spot in your bag. Call it fuel for the drive home.
Thanksgiving pickups are a thing here. Fresh pies leave alongside other goodies for holiday tables.
Timing is worth thinking about. Friday afternoons and Saturdays run the busiest, while weekday mornings stay calmer.
The market is open Monday through Saturday and closed Sunday. Don’t plan a Sunday pie run and end up staring at a locked door.
Coffee is available, which makes an early stop easier. A free parking lot keeps things simple.
There’s no delivery, so this one is a get-in-the-car mission. Shelby sits close to orchard country, which makes the trip feel right.
Order ahead, swing by on a weekday morning, and grab a fritter. Nobody needs to know it never made it home.
Address: 5393 W Shelby Rd, Shelby, MI 49455
6. Nantucket Baking Company – Fuller Ave
Pies and dinner rolls in one pickup? Grand Rapids families have figured out that combo on Fuller Avenue.
Nantucket Baking Company is a versatile bakery with artisanal breads at its core. Pastries and desserts fill out the rest of the case.
For Thanksgiving, pies and rolls make a natural pairing. One stop handles both the bread basket and the finale.
The croissants have a strong local following. Some consider them the best in Grand Rapids.
Fresh cheesecake is another option if your crew craves variety. Cupcakes and pastries round things out.
The bakery also makes wedding cakes. That tells you they’re used to big, important orders.
Keep in mind this is a takeout shop. There’s no dine-in and no restroom, so plan a quick in-and-out.
Saturday mornings and afternoons run the busiest. Weekdays are noticeably quieter if you can sneak away.
Hours stretch early, starting at 7 AM daily. Sunday closes at 2 PM, so don’t sleep in.
Coffee is available to help with that early start. Parking includes a free lot and a paid lot.
Here’s the move. Order your pies and rolls together ahead of time, then pick them up on a weekday if possible.
Your guests get fresh bread and pie, and you skip kneading anything. Everyone wins, especially your arms.
Address: 1308 Fuller Ave NE, Grand Rapids, MI 49505
7. Sweet Potato Sensations
Sweet potato pie, sweet potato cheesecake, sweet potato ice cream, and even a sweet potato waffle. This Detroit bakery picked a lane and filled it beautifully.
Sweet Potato Sensations builds its menu around one star ingredient. Pies, cookies, cake, cobbler, and muffins all get the treatment.
The whole 9-inch sweet potato pie is the classic order. Sweet potato pecan pie gives you two holiday favorites in one slice.
Banana pudding cheesecake also shows up. It’s a fun extra for anyone who skips pie, though who are these people?
Savory food is on the menu too. The Jive Turkey Sandwich and black eye pea and collard green soup are worth noting.
There’s even a whole wing dinner with greens and yams. Cornbread and cream cheese pound cake slices complete the spread.
The space itself has personality. Soulful music, creative art, and items like clothing and jewelry fill the shop.
Holiday demand runs high here. Lines for pre-ordered pies get long, so build in some extra time.
Plan around the hours. The shop is closed Monday through Wednesday and opens at noon Thursday through Sunday.
Delivery and in-store pickup are available. Free street parking helps on busy days.
Order your pie early and maybe add a waffle. Thanksgiving in Michigan deserves at least one sweet potato surprise.
Address: 17337 Lahser Rd, Detroit, MI 48219
8. Grand Traverse Pie Company Front Street
Traverse City is where this pie company got its start back in 1996. Ordering a holiday pie on Front Street feels a bit like going straight to the source.
The shop serves sweet and savory pies plus classic cafe fare. Michigan-grown ingredients like cherries and blueberries play a big role.
Strawberry Rhubarb Crumb is a fan favorite here. The Big Chicken Pot Pie earns plenty of love too.
Craving something other than a full pie? An apple dumpling, cinnamon rolls, and a frosted sugar cookie are all on deck.
The Front Street Apple Pie is named after the street where Grand Traverse Pie Company opened its original shop in 1996. Local pride, now with flaky layers.
Lunch fans can grab a GT Chicken Salad Croissant or a Grilled Lighthouse Turkey Cheddar. A BLT also makes the list.
Some families even take pies home to bake themselves for the holiday. That fresh-from-your-oven moment is a nice trick for guests.
The busiest stretches hit Wednesday mornings, Friday afternoons, and Saturdays. Sunday mornings tend to be calmer.
Dogs are allowed outside, and outdoor seating is available. Kids get their own menu and high chairs.
Hours run 8 AM to 6 PM Monday through Saturday. Sunday hours run from 9 AM to 4 PM.
Order ahead before the November rush. Cherry country deserves a cherry-filled table.
Address: 525 W Front St, Traverse City, MI 49684
9. Crust – A Baking Company
Brick walls, fresh bread, and a mixed berry crumb pie that people talk about. Fenton’s downtown has a pretty sweet anchor.
Crust – a baking company is a bright bakery and cafe. Daily breads, pies, and sweets share space with sandwiches and salads.
Mixed berry crumb is one of the standout pies. Molasses cookies make a great add-on for the car ride.
The bread game is strong too. Henry Street Provincial is a menu highlight worth bringing to the dinner table.
Breakfast here gets creative. Cinnamon Roll Bread Pudding French Toast sounds like a dessert wearing a breakfast costume.
Classic Eggs Benedict and Fenton’s Finest Grilled Cheese are also on the menu. A pie pickup can easily turn into brunch.
Holiday bakery orders are part of the routine here. Planning ahead keeps you from settling for whatever’s left.
Weekends bring the biggest crowds, especially Saturday and Sunday mornings. Weekday visits are calmer.
Curbside pickup is available, which is great when the car’s full of grocery bags. Delivery is an option too.
The bakery is closed Monday. It opens at 8 AM Tuesday through Sunday.
Free and paid parking are both nearby. Grab your pie, a loaf, and maybe that French toast for yourself.
Address: 104 W Caroline St, Fenton, MI 48430
10. Zingerman’s Bakehouse
Hungarian pastries next to pecan pie might seem like an odd couple. At this Ann Arbor bakehouse, they get along great.
Zingerman’s Bakehouse offers breads, bagels, pastries, and Hungarian classics. Soups and sandwiches fill out the menu.
Pecan pie is a holiday highlight. The bakery is known for baked goods made with simple, quality ingredients.
Bread lovers have serious options. The sourdough is vegan, and the croissants pull plenty of fans.
Sweet extras include crullers, cupcakes, and coffee cake. Biscuits and scones make a strong case for Thanksgiving morning.
The staff has a reputation for going above and beyond. That matters when your order list gets long.
Hours are generous, from 7 AM to 7 PM every day. Few bakeries on this list offer that kind of flexibility.
Still, the place gets busy on most mornings and afternoons. Tuesday and Wednesday evenings tend to be quieter.
Curbside pickup makes holiday grabs easier. In-store pickup works too if you want to browse.
Free parking is available in a lot and on the street. A gender-neutral restroom is on site.
Order your pie early, then add a loaf for the table. Ann Arbor makes Michigan’s holiday pie hunt feel a little more delicious.
Address: 3711 Plaza Dr, Ann Arbor, MI 48108