A Sicilian pizza topped with slow-simmered meatball and sausage bolognese just took first place at the International Pizza Challenge in Las Vegas.
It’s called the Sunday Sauce Sicilian, and it was inspired by traditional Italian-American Sunday dinners and family recipes.
That win came from a small corner shop in Ohio that opened in October 2024. Barely over a year in, it was already beating thick-crust pies from across the country.
The year before, its spicy pepperoni pie and a loaded chicken cutlet sandwich both placed at the same Las Vegas event.
The building has its own story, too. It sat empty for decades before a local family brought it back with a bright mural and a scratch kitchen.
I like the thought of both, an old storefront and a brand-new trophy shelf.
So how does a former tile store become a Sicilian pizza powerhouse?
A First-Place Sicilian Pie Inspired By Family Sunday Dinners

Las Vegas handed out a big honor in 2026, and it went home to Franky’s Pizza and Delicatessen.
The Sunday Sauce Sicilian won first place in the Sicilian category at the International Pizza Challenge.
It also grabbed fourth place overall in the pan division.
That pan division included all kinds of thick-crust styles. So this pie wasn’t only beating other Sicilians.
It held its own against a much bigger crowd.
The pizza is built upside down. Olive oil, a house white seasoning, and mozzarella go on first, then the sauce lands on top.
That sauce is a slow-simmered bolognese made with beef and pork meatball plus mild Italian sausage.
Seasoned Italian breadcrumbs, grated Romano, and fresh basil finish it. The idea comes from traditional Italian family dinners.
Owner Ben Hoover drew inspiration from the long-simmered Sunday sauces and family gatherings that have shaped Italian-American cooking for generations.
Honestly, that’s the sweetest part. A family Sunday dinner turned into a trophy on a national stage.
Not bad for a shop that opened in October 2024.
If you’re planning a visit to Warren, Ohio, this is the pie to put at the top of your list. It’s a delicious way to taste what earned the shop its spotlight.
The Spicy Pepperoni Pie Got There First

Before the 2026 gold, there was 2025. Ben Hoover took fifth place at the International Pizza Expo in Las Vegas with his Sicilian-style Spicy Pepperoni.
It was a strong early sign that this Warren kitchen meant business.
The star here is a house-made Italian chili crunch oil. It blends chilis, herbs, garlic, and toasted sesame seeds.
Then it’s triple-fried in extra-virgin olive oil, which sounds like a lot of effort for one drizzle.
Underneath that oil sits rich tomato sauce, capicola, and cup-and-char pepperoni. Those little pepperoni cups curl up and crisp at the edges as they bake.
Add the chili crunch, and you’ve got heat, crunch, and plenty of flavor in every square.
Here’s the good news for spice fans. This award winner stays on the regular menu.
You don’t need perfect timing or a lucky day to try it.
The same chili crunch shows up on the Hot! Bread appetizer too.
That one adds red onions and Parmesan. So if you love the oil, you have two ways to get your fix at one counter.
Bring a friend who claims they can handle spice. This pie will happily test that claim.
Bakers Start Before Sunrise For All That Dough

Around 800 pounds of dough. That’s what this kitchen makes every single day, according to the shop.
The bakers start before 6 a.m. to keep up.
Every batch gets a 24-hour fermentation. That long rest helps build deeper flavor in the crust.
Then each piece is portioned, stretched, rolled, and proofed by hand.
The result is the Sicilian style Franky’s Pizza and Delicatessen is known for. The crust is lofty, light, and crispy, and it’s cut into rectangles.
The shop calls it New York Sicilian with a local Mahoning Valley twist.
The same fresh dough powers the sandwich side too. House-made rolls come out of that same morning routine.
Four full-time bakers are part of the 15-person crew.
That’s a lot of people focused on bread for one small corner shop. It explains why the crust gets so much attention.
Square pizza fans, this is your kind of place.
A quick tip helps here. The shop opens at 11 a.m. and may close when things sell out.
So showing up earlier is a smart move if you have your heart set on a certain pie. Dough this popular doesn’t wait around.
Chubby Rolls Make These Sandwiches Hard To Forget

Paffuto. That’s the name the owners gave their house-made sandwich rolls.
It’s an Italian word meaning plump or chubby, and the label fits a sturdy deli roll nicely.
Remember, this is a pizza and delicatessen. The deli half earned its own trophy in 2025.
The Countach sandwich placed 13th at the International Pizza Expo in Las Vegas.
It stacks basil pesto, a breaded chicken cutlet, and prosciutto di Parma. Fresh mozzarella and roasted red peppers round it out.
Yes, it’s named like a sports car, and it’s built like one too.
Franky’s Italian is a steady bestseller. It layers ham, Genoa salami, pistachio mortadella, and provolone.
Lettuce, tomato, red onion, olive oil, vinegar, and dried oregano finish the job.
The Hunter’s Triple goes even bigger. It brings ham, house-made honey roasted turkey, and house-made roast beef with Swiss.
Mayo and yellow mustard keep things classic.
That in-house roast beef is a nice detail. Sauces, spice blends, and hot peppers in oil are made from scratch here too.
The owners have even talked about making their own capicola and mortadella someday. For a deli counter, that’s real dedication to the craft.
An Old Tile Store Got A Very Tasty Second Act

Built in 1952, this two-story building once held the Warren Tile & Floor store. Then it sat vacant from the late 1990s on.
That’s a long stretch for any storefront to wait for its next chapter.
Ben and Emily Hoover bought the building in June 2023. When Ben first saw it, he pictured a neighborhood corner pizza shop.
A little over a year later, that picture became real.
The first floor got a full renovation. It covers roughly 1,400 square feet, and the kitchen was planned with great care.
New custom-made equipment went in, and the ovens came from Dunbar, Pennsylvania.
Upstairs is another story. The second floor hasn’t been renovated yet.
Plans call for it to become storage down the road.
Outside, a colorful mural runs along the corner building. It makes the place easy to spot from the street.
The shop’s own website shows that mural front and center.
It’s fun to think about the building’s journey. Floors and tiles once came through these doors.
Now it’s rectangular pies and stacked sandwiches. Few old buildings in Ohio get such a delicious makeover, and this one wears it well.
Grandpa Franky Gets The Name On The Door

Ben Hoover’s German grandfather was named Franky. The shop carries his name.
Some recipes, though, lean on Ben’s Sicilian grandfather for inspiration.
So two family branches share credit here. One gets the sign, and the other shapes the flavors.
That feels like a fair trade at any family dinner table.
This is very much a family operation. Ben runs the kitchen side as owner and operator.
His wife Emily co-owns the business and manages the front of the house.
Franky’s Pizza and Delicatessen also belongs to a bigger family group. It’s called the Monday Dinner Project.
That group includes Cockeye BBQ and Cockeye Creamery too.
The connections show up on the menu. The Westsider pizza uses brisket and sauce from Cockeye BBQ.
The Italian ices are co-branded with Cockeye Creamery and were developed by Max Hoover.
Kitchen manager Jesse Ruiz has a family-group story as well. He started as a cook at Cockeye BBQ before moving into his current role.
It’s nice to see people grow inside the same circle.
The owners say they want Franky’s to feel like a welcoming home. With grandparents on the sign and in the recipes, it already has a head start.
The Menu Never Sits Still For Long

Every two to three weeks, something new shows up. Franky’s calls these Spotlight Specials.
They’re rotating pizzas and sandwiches that let the kitchen play with seasonal ingredients.
It’s a clever system. Fans get a reason to check back often.
The kitchen gets to test ideas before deciding what sticks.
The regular pizza lineup already covers lots of ground. The Brier Hill (Old World) pie nods to a lesser-known Ohio style.
The White pizza brings olive oil, house Hungarian hot peppers in oil, mozzarella, and herbed ricotta.
Then there’s Red, White and Green, which the menu also calls The One With The Stripes. Franky’s Supreme, Valley Veggie, Chicken Bacon Ranch, and BBQ Chicken and Bacon fill out the board.
Picky eaters, consider yourselves covered.
Starters are worth a look too. Options include Cheesy Bread, a gluten-free Cheesy Bread, Fried Mozzarella, Fried Zucchini, and Fried Beef Ravioli.
Footlong Strombolis and French fries are on there as well.
Salad lovers can choose House, Caesar, or Antipasto entree salads. And for dessert, those Italian ices make a cool finish.
With specials changing so often, your second visit may look different from your first.
Plan For Takeout And A Bright Little Room

Small and cheerful sums up the space. Franky’s runs mostly as a carryout spot, so it’s built for grabbing food and heading out.
Seating is very limited inside.
A yellow wall decorated with framed photos, paintings, and decorative pieces appears on the shop’s website. It gives the room a homey, collected look.
That matches the owners’ goal of a welcoming place for families and friends.
Timing matters here. The shop is open Wednesday through Sunday from 11 a.m. to 8 p.m.
It’s closed on Mondays and Tuesdays.
Keep in mind the shop may close when it sells out. With about 350 pizzas going out daily, that can happen.
A little planning saves you from a sad pizza-less drive home.
Online ordering is offered through the restaurant’s website, though it may be paused outside business hours or when items sell out. Calling ahead is another option.
Catering is also listed as an option for bigger gatherings.
Think of it like a classic neighborhood corner shop. You come in, pick your pies or sandwiches, and carry the goods to your next stop.
Simple, friendly, and focused on the food that earned all those awards.
Downtown Warren Makes A Great Pizza Detour

You’ll find the shop at 125 Scott St NE, Warren, OH 44483. It sits in downtown Warren in Trumbull County, Ohio.
Look for the colorful mural on the corner building.
Since opening, Franky’s Pizza and Delicatessen has drawn strong community support. Selling around 350 pizzas a day is no small feat.
That’s a lot of rectangles leaving one corner shop.
Its rise also put a spotlight on the Mahoning Valley pizza scene. PMQ Pizza Magazine profiled Chef Ben Hoover and the shop.
The story focused on his Sicilian approach, dough production, and kitchen systems.
That’s a big deal for a place that opened in October 2024. National press, two years of Las Vegas awards, and a busy daily routine.
Not a bad start for a former tile store.
Warren makes a fun day trip for food lovers. Pair a pizza run here with stops at the family’s other spots, Cockeye BBQ and Cockeye Creamery.
That’s dinner and dessert sorted in one family loop.
Grab a Sunday Sauce Sicilian, a Countach, and something from the latest Spotlight Special. Then you can judge the trophy case for yourself, one crispy corner at a time.