TRAVELMAG

9 North Carolina Sandwich Shops Serving Pimento Cheese

David Reed 6 min read
9 North Carolina Sandwich Shops Serving Pimento Cheese

A paper-wrapped sandwich, still warm and oozing orange cheese at the edges, can change a whole road trip. North Carolina is full of small delis and corner counters where pimento cheese is treated like a treasure, not a side note.

Some spots look plain from the parking lot, but one bite tells you someone in the kitchen really cares. Grab a napkin, because these nine stops are worth the drive this weekend.

1. Poppyseed Market, Raleigh, NC

Poppyseed Market, Raleigh, NC
© Poppyseed Market, Raleigh, NC

Pimento cheese three ways is the move at this cheerful North Raleigh bistro. The kitchen serves it as a dip with pita points, tucked into sandwiches, and scooped onto a salad plate.

It even shows up grilled in the deli section.

The spread is homemade, and it has a bold personality that sets it apart from the tubs at the grocery store. Pair it with the house corn bread or homemade mac and cheese for a full comfort lunch.

The menu changes daily with new specials, though the regular lineup holds steady.

Inside, the room is colorful, cozy, and casual, with a deli counter up front and table service available. Free parking makes a quick stop easy.

Hours run 11 AM to 8:30 PM most weekdays, later on Friday and Saturday, with a short lunch-only window on Monday and Sundays closed.

2. Merritt’s Grill, Chapel Hill, NC

Merritt's Grill, Chapel Hill, NC
© Merritt’s Grill, Chapel Hill, NC

Ask anyone in Chapel Hill about Merritt’s, and the first word out of their mouth will probably be BLT. That famous sandwich gets the spotlight, but the pimento cheese sandwich quietly earns its own loyal following.

Order it with a cup of tomato soup and you have a lunch that feels like a rainy-day hug. The storied corner store keeps things down-home, with counter service, baked treats, and a slice of coconut cake for dessert.

Out back, a garden patio framed by bamboo offers corn hole and plenty of sunshine. Dogs are welcome, and there is usually a line, so plan for a short wait.

Doors open at 7 AM Monday through Saturday and close at 4 PM.

3. Neal’s Deli, Carrboro, NC

Neal's Deli, Carrboro, NC
© Neal’s Deli, Carrboro, NC

Scratch cooking is the whole philosophy at this tiny Carrboro deli. The pastrami is made in house, the biscuits come out of their own oven, and the pimento cheese gets the same careful attention.

Try it two ways. A homemade biscuit split and filled with pimento cheese makes a fine Saturday morning bite, while the hot pimento cheese sandwich with spinach is a lunch that feels a little bit fancy.

Fans of bigger sandwiches can also chase the muffuletta or a towering Reuben. Hours are short, Tuesday through Friday from 11:30 AM to 2:30 PM and Saturday from 9 AM, so time your visit.

Free parking nearby helps.

4. Piper’s In the Park, Durham, NC

Piper's In the Park, Durham, NC
© Piper’s In the Park, Durham, NC

Portobello mushrooms and pimento cheese sound like an odd couple until you taste them together. That earthy, creamy match is the signature twist at this weekday lunch cafe near Research Triangle Park.

Everything is handmade, from sandwiches to fresh soups and salads, and the daily specials keep regulars guessing. The chop and pimento cheese combo is a smart pick when you want a little of both.

Service is quick, portions are generous, and parking is easy. Just remember the schedule: Monday through Friday, 10:30 AM to 2:30 PM only.

5. Wildwood Community Market & Deli, Boone, NC

Wildwood Community Market & Deli, Boone, NC
© Wildwood Community Market & Deli, Boone, NC

Mountain air makes everybody hungry, and Boone has the perfect answer. This community market blends grocery shopping with a busy deli counter full of fresh sandwiches and house-made sides.

Go straight for the Deluxe with pimento cheese and hot honey. The sweet heat against sharp, creamy cheese is a combo you will be thinking about all the way back down the Blue Ridge.

The chicken and pimento sandwich is another strong pick.

Vegans have plenty of options too, and dogs are welcome inside and out. Parking downtown can be tricky, so walk if you can.

Open daily, with shorter Sunday hours.

6. CheeseSmith, Wilmington, NC

CheeseSmith, Wilmington, NC
© CheeseSmith, Wilmington, NC

Maple syrup on a grilled cheese? At this Cargo District favorite in Wilmington, absolutely.

The kitchen builds creative sandwiches stacked with cheese, bacon, and pimento cheese, then finishes them with a sweet drizzle.

The Duke is the classic grilled pimento cheese for purists. Adventurous eaters can try pimento cheese on a BLT, a pairing that tastes like summer at the coast.

Do not skip the fries. Parm fries are a crisp, salty sidekick.

Seating spills into a sunny courtyard, and kids and dogs fit right in. Open Tuesday through Sunday, 11 AM to 9 PM.

7. Rhino Market & Deli, Charlotte, NC

Rhino Market & Deli, Charlotte, NC
© Rhino Market & Deli, Charlotte, NC

Early birds and night owls both win at this Charlotte market. Rhino opens at 7 AM and stays open late most nights, which makes it handy for a breakfast stop or an after-work bite.

The menu leans eclectic, and the pimento grilled cheese is the pick for cheese lovers. Sandwiches come in a nice size with fresh ingredients, and the hot Sicilian has its own fans.

Shelves stock local breads and readymade pastas, so you can grab dinner for later too. Free Wi-Fi makes it an easy spot for a laptop lunch.

8. Fratelli’s Delicatessen, Apex, NC

Fratelli's Delicatessen, Apex, NC
© Fratelli’s Delicatessen, Apex, NC

Seven days a week, from 7:30 AM to 8 PM, Fratelli’s keeps the griddle hot in Apex. That steady schedule makes it one of the easiest stops on this list to plan around.

The Pimento Grilled Cheese is a menu highlight, and quality ingredients give the spread a rich, balanced flavor. Round it out with the potato salad or the vegan pasta salad.

Families will appreciate the kids’ menu, high chairs, and outdoor seating. Weekends get busy, so expect a short wait around lunch.

9. Sand Hill Kitchen, Asheville, NC

Sand Hill Kitchen, Asheville, NC
© Sand Hill Kitchen, Asheville, NC

Fill up the tank, then fill up yourself. This scratch kitchen inside a gas station west of downtown Asheville surprises everyone who pulls in expecting a quick snack.

The LOVE burger arrives topped with homemade pimento cheese, and gluten-free bread is available. You can also add that pimento to the fried chicken sandwiches, a favorite move among regulars.

Morning visitors should try the fried chicken biscuit. A drive-through keeps things speedy if you are heading toward the Blue Ridge Parkway for fall color.

Hours are short and vary, roughly Tuesday through Saturday mornings to early afternoon.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *