TRAVELMAG

10 Colorado Restaurants That Serve Giant Pizza Slices That Take Two Hands To Hold

Elliot Shaw 12 min read
10 Colorado Restaurants That Serve Giant Pizza Slices That Take Two Hands To Hold

One pizza shop in this state hands you a small slicer along with your slice. Why?

Because the slice comes from a 24-inch pie, and it is too big to tackle in one go.

That detail made me laugh out loud. Then I learned another spot bakes 28-inch pies, and a different one warns right in its own description that you might need both hands.

I love that Colorado has a whole little world of pizza places competing to make your plate look small. These are slices you fold, steady, and plan around.

A napkin is not optional here.

So I went hunting for the biggest ones I could find. The list stretches from mountain towns to college towns to busy city streets.

Which one would beat your appetite first?

1. Fat Sully’s NY Pizza

Fat Sully's NY Pizza
© Fat Sully’s NY Pizza

Most restaurants don’t warn you about their food in advance. Fat Sully’s NY Pizza does, telling guests they might need both hands.

The shop proudly promises giant slices of NY-style pizza. It also admits it likes to go big, which feels like the understatement of the year.

You’ll find it on South Tejon Street in downtown Colorado Springs. It’s a casual pizzeria with counter service, so you order, grab a seat, and get ready for the fold.

Pizza isn’t the only heavyweight here. The menu also features double smash burgers and fried chicken sandwiches, plus fries and sides.

Got a friend who swears they don’t want pizza? Point them to the burgers and keep the slices for yourself.

There’s a full vegetarian menu too. That makes it easier for mixed groups to agree on one stop without a long debate.

Want fresh air with your giant slice? Look for the rooftop seating, a fun perk for a sunny Colorado afternoon.

Night owls, take note of the hours. It stays open until midnight most nights and until 2 AM on Fridays and Saturdays.

The shop is open on Thursdays, with posted hours from 8 AM to midnight. Showing up hungry to a locked door is nobody’s idea of fun.

Families are welcome, with high chairs, a kids’ menu, and changing tables. It doesn’t take reservations, so just roll in when the craving hits.

Address: 528 S Tejon St, Colorado Springs, CO 80903

2. Breckenridge Ale House & Pizza

Breckenridge Ale House & Pizza
© Breckenridge Ale House & Pizza

A slice that comes with its own cutting tool? That’s the deal with the giant slice at Breckenridge Ale House & Pizza.

The big one is cut from a 24-inch pie. It’s so large that the staff hands you a small slicer to help divide it.

Slices come in three sizes, and the biggest is the true giant. Ordering a smaller slice next to it makes a funny photo for scale.

The pizza here is thin with a crispy crust. That crunch helps the slice hold up while you wrestle it toward your mouth.

Need a warm-up act? Garlic knots are a popular starter, though you may want to save room for the main event.

The menu even lists a vegan regular slice. Plant-based eaters can join the slice challenge without missing out.

Sports fans get big TVs to watch the game. The spot also hosts live music, adding some extra energy to a mountain night out.

It sits on South Main Street in Breckenridge, right where skiers and summer hikers wander after a long day outside. Few things hit the spot like a giant slice after time at altitude.

Service is quick, and both counter and table service are available. There’s outdoor seating, and dogs are allowed outside.

Hours run until 9 PM most nights and 10 PM on Fridays and Saturdays. No reservations, so arrive ready to claim a table.

Address: 520 S Main St, Breckenridge, CO 80424

3. Cosmo’s Pizza

Cosmo's Pizza
© Cosmo’s Pizza

Foot-long slices are the headline at Cosmo’s Pizza in Denver. Yes, a single slice can stretch about a foot.

Somehow, that big triangle stays sturdy enough to carry plenty of toppings. The thin New York-style crust is strong yet light, which is a neat trick.

You’ll find it on North Grant Street in Capitol Hill. It’s a no-fuss spot built mostly around takeout and delivery, though you can dine in too.

Ordering is simple at the counter. There’s no table service, so grab your slice and find a spot.

Flavor fans should look for the Spicy Ranch. It’s one of the shop’s best-known picks and a fun break from plain pepperoni.

Classic eaters still have options, including cheese and pepperoni pizza. Calzones are on the menu for anyone who wants their pizza folded on purpose.

Vegetarians get a full menu of choices. That keeps group orders easy when everyone wants something different.

Late cravings? Cosmo’s stays open until midnight seven days a week, which makes it a handy stop after an evening out.

Weekend evenings get busy, especially Saturday and Sunday nights. Mornings run quieter if you’d rather skip a line.

Parking is often easy, with a free lot and free street parking. Dogs are welcome outside if your pup wants to sniff the crust from a distance.

Address: 550 N Grant St, Denver, CO 80203

4. Slice 420

Slice 420
© Slice 420

Twenty inches is a lot of pizza for one pie. At Slice 420, those Jumbo XL pies get cut into slices that call for a two-handed grip.

The shop sits in the historic Old Colorado City district of Colorado Springs. It’s a family-run spot with an easygoing feel and a patio.

Here’s a nice surprise: the vegan slice gets serious attention. One favorite features caramelized onions and juicy red peppers on a crispy crust.

Gluten-free diners aren’t left out either. A cauliflower crust option is light and fluffy, and the slices still come big.

Craving something meaty? The menu includes Chicken Bacon Ranch and Chicken Parm.

Cheese lovers can go for Quattro Formaggio. Square pizzas are another way to switch up your shape.

Save room if you can, because the chocolate-shelled cannoli sounds like a sweet finish. Garlic rolls are also on hand for a snack.

Watch the calendar before you go. Slice 420 is closed on Mondays, but it is open on Thursdays.

Parking can be a bit tricky in this part of town. Give yourself a few extra minutes to find a space.

Fridays and Saturday afternoons tend to be the busiest times. A weekday morning visit could mean a calmer meal with your jumbo slice.

Address: 2501 W Colorado Ave #108, Colorado Springs, CO 80904

5. Pizza Casbah

Pizza Casbah
© Pizza Casbah

A 28-inch pizza sounds like something built for a team. Pizza Casbah in Fort Collins makes one anyway.

The slices from these East Coast-style pies come out huge. Expect a crispy crust with a light outer crunch.

This humble spot sits on West Laurel Street near Colorado State University. Students are a big part of the crowd, which makes sense for a place this budget-friendly.

The shop calls itself community-oriented. It makes homemade sauces and serves wings alongside the pizza.

Dessert deserves a mention here. The zeppolis are a fan favorite, and the garlic knots work great as a side.

Need a break between bites? There are arcade games, so you can rest your arms after holding that slice.

Plant-based eaters will be happy to see a full vegan menu. A full vegetarian menu is available too.

Service moves fast at the counter. That’s handy when you only have a short lunch break between classes or errands.

Hours run until 10 PM most nights and 11 PM on Fridays and Saturdays. Weekend evenings tend to get busy.

Parking near campus can be tough, so walking or biking might be smart. Fort Collins is a bike-friendly town, after all.

Address: 126 W Laurel St, Fort Collins, CO 80524

6. Big Bill’s New York Pizza

Big Bill's New York Pizza
© Big Bill’s New York Pizza

With a name like Big Bill’s, small slices were never really an option. The large slices here can be bigger than your head.

That’s exactly how a New York slice should feel. The thin crust has a crunch, and it folds the classic way.

Big Bill’s New York Pizza sits on South Holly Street in Centennial. It’s a New York-focused pizzeria with table service and a relaxed feel.

Toppings come in generous amounts without making the slice too greasy. The combo pizza is one to look for if you like a little of everything.

Pizza is only part of the story. The menu covers Italian staples like eggplant parmigiana and chicken scampi.

There’s also a meat pie for anyone who wants extra heft. Garlic knots make a solid starter.

Finish with the homemade cannoli. A crisp shell is a nice ending after all that folding and chewing.

Families have it easy here, with a kids’ menu and high chairs. Coffee is on offer too.

Heads up on timing, since Big Bill’s closes at 8 PM. It’s open on Thursdays from 11 AM to 8 PM, according to the restaurant’s official website.

Curbside pickup is available, but there’s no delivery. Plenty of free parking makes the drive easy.

Address: 8243 S Holly St, Centennial, CO 80122

7. SliceWorks

SliceWorks
© SliceWorks

Half a pound for one slice? Some specialty slices at SliceWorks hit that kind of weight.

The shop is known for giant double-crusted options. Think of a pizza slice and calzone teaming up for one hearty bite.

Regular slices come large too, with a crispy crust and plenty of cheese. The sauce gets plenty of love as well.

Creativity shows up across the menu. The Big Mac Slice and the Pizza Alla Vodka Slice are two playful picks.

Like a little heat? Try the Jalapeño Popper.

White pizza and a classic pepperoni slice cover the simpler side.

SliceWorks sits on East Colfax Avenue in Denver. It has a city feel and serves NY-style pizza by the pie or the slice.

Pasta and subs round out the menu. A bacon cheeseburger option and tiramisu add even more choices.

Need pizza at 2 AM? On Fridays and Saturdays, it stays open until 2:30 AM.

Other days, it’s open until 11 PM. Whole pizzas are often ready in about 15 to 20 minutes.

Friday and Saturday nights draw the biggest crowds. Monday mornings are much quieter if you’d like a calm slice.

Address: 700 E Colfax Ave, Denver, CO 80203

8. New York Pizza Aspen

New York Pizza Aspen
© New York Pizza Aspen

Paper plates in Aspen might sound surprising. At New York Pizza Aspen, they hold huge slices with zero fuss.

This counter-serve pizzeria keeps things simple on East Hyman Avenue in downtown Aspen. You order, grab your plate, and use both hands.

The slices are wide, thin, and foldable. Holding one with a single hand is asking for a flop.

Prices are reasonable for a mountain resort town. That makes it a smart stop between ski runs or summer hikes.

Want more than a slice? An extra large pizza is available for groups.

The menu also covers vegan pizza and gluten-free pizza. Garlic bread and salads give you a few sides to share.

Calzones here are called huge, and that fits the theme. Extra toppings let you build your slice your way.

Service is fast, and the shop offers a great view. Not bad for a casual spot with paper plates.

The restaurant opens daily at 11:30 AM, although closing hours may vary by season. Late-night hunger in Colorado’s ski country has a clear answer.

Parking downtown can be tough to find. Walking from your hotel or the slopes might be the easier move.

Address: 409 E Hyman Ave, Aspen, CO 81611

9. Upstate Pizzeria

Upstate Pizzeria
© Upstate Pizzeria

Reheated pizza usually sounds sad. At Upstate Pizzeria, slices get a trip back into the oven right before you eat, and that’s the good kind.

Those slices come out huge and hot. The pizza is thin, while the crust edge stays thick.

Upstate sits on Austin Bluffs Parkway in Colorado Springs. It focuses on New York-style pizza and Buffalo wings.

The name hints at upstate New York roots. Wings on the menu fit that story nicely.

Looking for a standout pie? The Large 16 Hot Honey Pepperoni brings sweet and spicy together.

Vegan and vegetarian eaters get full menus. That’s a big plus for mixed groups.

The space leans casual and quiet, though it also hosts live music. Sports fans can catch a game here too.

Service is quick and prices are fair. It works well for a fast lunch or an easy dinner.

Hours run from 11 AM to 9 PM every day. Friday evenings are the busiest time.

Tuesday and Wednesday mornings tend to be quiet. Free parking is usually easy to find, and dogs can join you outside.

Address: 4621 Austin Bluffs Pkwy, Colorado Springs, CO 80918

10. Abo’s Pizza North Boulder

Abo's Pizza North Boulder
© Abo’s Pizza North Boulder

Quick math lesson: one slice here can equal a quarter of a medium pizza. That’s how Abo’s Pizza North Boulder plays the size game.

Abo’s is a local Boulder pizzeria chain. This North Boulder location sits on Iris Avenue and serves New York-style pies.

The sauce is light, and the ingredients are fresh. The dough has a homemade taste that stands out.

Budget watchers, rejoice. This spot falls on the low end for cost, so a huge slice won’t cost a huge amount.

Vegan diners get a full menu. Vegetarians do too, which fits Boulder’s style nicely.

The vibe is casual and laid-back. You order at the counter and grab a seat inside or out.

Families are welcome, and high chairs are available. Groups and college students are a big part of the crowd.

Hours run from 11 AM to 9 PM most days. On Saturday, Abo’s stays open until 10 PM.

Weekday lunch hours can get busy. Plan a little ahead if you’re squeezing it into a short break.

Free parking is usually easy here. Grab a slice, use both hands, and enjoy one of the most Colorado ways to finish a day in Boulder.

Address: 2761 Iris Ave, Boulder, CO 80304