TRAVELMAG

For Over 70 Years This Grand Lake Eatery Has Been The Sweetest Spot For Colorado Ice Cream

Emma Turner 10 min read
For Over 70 Years This Grand Lake Eatery Has Been The Sweetest Spot For Colorado Ice Cream

Huckleberry ice cream, hand-dipped caramel apples, and snow cones all come out of the same small walk-up window. That window has been serving sweets on this spot since 1953.

I like knowing a scoop can carry that much history.

The shop started out under a different name, run by a woman named Polly. Today it belongs to a new owner who bought it in 2016.

She’s now the second-longest-running owner in the shop’s long story.

The lake itself sits just a short stroll away. I can’t imagine a better way to cool down after a mountain day in Colorado.

Cone in hand, water in view, and a boardwalk under your feet.

So how does a tiny sweet shop keep people coming back for more than seven decades? The answer starts with what’s in the freezer.

Seventy-Three Years Of Scoops Started With A Woman Named Polly

Seventy-Three Years Of Scoops Started With A Woman Named Polly
© Ceaira’s Sweet Shop

Back in 1953, a sweet shop opened on Grand Avenue under the name Polly’s Sweet Shop. That same spot is now Ceaira’s Sweet Shop, and the sweets never really stopped.

Ceaira bought the business in 2016 and gave it her own name. In 2026, the shop is celebrating ten years of her ownership and 73 years of a sweet shop at this location.

That’s a pretty wild run for a business built on ice cream. Plenty of shops come and go in a single summer.

This one has outlasted fads, decades, and a whole lot of melted cones.

Ceaira is now the second-longest-running owner in the shop’s history. Only Polly herself held the keys longer, which makes the handoff feel like a family tradition.

I love that the place kept its roots instead of starting over from scratch. The new name sits on top of an old story, and you can still feel that connection today.

So when you order here, you’re joining a line that stretches back to the Eisenhower years. Not bad for a cone, right?

It’s history you can actually eat, one scoop at a time.

Huckleberry Is The Flavor You Should Try First

Huckleberry Is The Flavor You Should Try First
© Ceaira’s Sweet Shop

Purple, fruity, and very mountain-y. Huckleberry is one of the flavors that sets the hand-scooped lineup apart at this little Colorado shop.

The shop is known for unique flavors like that one. It also keeps classic favorites around for anyone who wants a familiar scoop.

That mix matters when you’re ordering for a group. One person can chase something new while another sticks with a safe bet.

Nobody has to compromise, and nobody ends up staring sadly at the menu.

Here’s a tip worth remembering. If you’ve never tried huckleberry, a mountain town is a great place to start.

It feels right at home next to pine trees and cool lake air.

Gluten-free cones are available too. That’s a thoughtful touch for anyone who usually gets stuck with a cup while everyone else crunches away.

The flavor board can make decisions tough, so give yourself a minute. Pick one bold choice and one classic if you’re splitting.

That way you get a little adventure and a little comfort in the same visit, which sounds like the perfect summer plan to me.

Soft Serve Gets A Colorful Twist Here

Soft Serve Gets A Colorful Twist Here
© Ceaira’s Sweet Shop

Hand-scooped ice cream isn’t the only option at the window. Ceaira’s Sweet Shop also serves Flavorburst soft serve, which adds stripes of flavor right into the swirl.

It’s a fun pick for kids who love bright colors. Honestly, grown-ups aren’t exactly immune to it either.

Soft serve works great on a warm day when you want something light and quick. It’s also easier for little hands to manage than a tall tower of hard scoops.

Sundaes are on the menu as well. You can build a bigger treat if a simple cone feels too modest for the occasion.

Having both styles under one small roof is pretty handy. Your group doesn’t have to agree on scooped or swirled before getting in line.

My advice? Grab extra napkins no matter what you order.

Mountain sunshine and soft serve have a long history of racing each other, and the sunshine usually wins.

A sundae shared at a picnic table is a smart move for families. Everyone gets a spoon, everyone gets a bite, and nobody fights over who chose the best flavor.

Caramel Apples And Snow Cones Keep The Menu Interesting

Caramel Apples And Snow Cones Keep The Menu Interesting
© Ceaira’s Sweet Shop

Not everyone wants ice cream, and that’s totally fine here. The menu stretches way beyond the freezer case.

Hand-dipped caramel apples are one of the standout treats. They feel a little old-fashioned in the best way, like something from a county fair.

Snow cones are another option at Ceaira’s Sweet Shop. On a hot afternoon, shaved ice can feel even better than a scoop of anything.

Milkshakes and malts round out the classic side of the menu. A malt is a nice nod to the shop’s 1950s roots, too.

It’s hard to think of a more fitting order.

Ice cream sandwiches are also available for anyone who likes a treat with built-in handles. They’re easy to carry down toward the water.

This variety is great news for picky eaters. One kid wants a snow cone, another wants a shake, and a parent wants a caramel apple.

Everybody walks away happy.

The best strategy is to look over the full menu before you reach the window. That way you won’t panic and order the first thing you see.

Boba Lemonade At An Ice Cream Shop? Absolutely

Boba Lemonade At An Ice Cream Shop? Absolutely
© Ceaira’s Sweet Shop

Thirsty instead of hungry? The drink lineup might surprise you more than the ice cream case does.

Ceaira’s Sweet Shop offers Boba Lemonades, which bring chewy pearls into a bright, cold drink. Lotus drinks and Red Bull specialty drinks are on the menu too.

That’s a pretty modern lineup for a shop with roots in 1953. Polly probably never pictured boba coming out of her window.

Times change, and the menu changed with them.

These drinks are a smart choice when you’re heading back out on the trail. Something cold and fizzy can feel more refreshing than a heavy scoop.

They also give teens something to get excited about. Not every member of the family wants a classic cone, and that’s okay.

One quick heads-up is worth sharing. This is an ice cream shop, not a coffee shop, so plan your hot coffee stop elsewhere in town.

Treat the drinks as a fun bonus rather than the main event. Order a lemonade for the walk and a scoop for later, and you’ve covered both your thirst and your sweet tooth.

Save Room For A Bag Of Candy On The Way Out

Save Room For A Bag Of Candy On The Way Out
© Ceaira’s Sweet Shop

Sweet shop is right there in the name, so candy makes sense. A selection of candy is available alongside all the frozen treats.

Candy has one big advantage over ice cream. It won’t melt in your pocket on the drive home, at least not as fast.

That makes it a great souvenir for the road. Grabbing a little bag for later is a smart way to stretch the visit past the last bite of your cone.

It’s also an easy gift idea. Bringing sweets back for a neighbor or pet sitter beats another keychain any day.

Kids especially love picking out their own treats. Giving them a small budget turns it into a fun little lesson in choices.

Here’s my favorite plan for a mountain day. Eat the ice cream now and save the candy for the car ride.

You’ll thank yourself somewhere along the winding roads home.

A sweet shop that has lasted over seven decades knows what people like to carry home. Candy has been part of that magic all along, and it still fits the shop perfectly today.

The Boardwalk Location Puts The Lake Just Steps Away

The Boardwalk Location Puts The Lake Just Steps Away
© Ceaira’s Sweet Shop

Location is a big part of the charm. The shop sits right on the boardwalk in Grand Lake, Colorado, a short walk from the lake itself.

You’ll find it at 1106 Grand Ave, Grand Lake, CO 80447. It’s on the last block of Grand Ave, across the street from Sagebrush BBQ.

That makes it easy to plan a full afternoon. Have a meal nearby, then walk over for dessert.

Your evening basically plans itself.

Ordering happens at walk-up windows, which keeps things simple. You grab your treat and head right back outside into the fresh mountain air.

The short stroll to the water is the real bonus. Few views go better with a cone than a sparkling mountain lake.

A quick tip for planning your visit is to park once and explore on foot. The boardwalk makes wandering easy, and you won’t miss anything rushing past in a car.

Grand Lake is a small town, so everything feels close together. That walkable layout is exactly why a sweet shop on this block has stayed such a natural stop for so long.

Look For The Historic Plaque Before You Order

Look For The Historic Plaque Before You Order
© Ceaira’s Sweet Shop

History buffs, this part is for you. The shop is featured on the Grand Lake Historical Society’s Walking Tour.

Ceaira’s Sweet Shop also displays an official historic plaque. It’s a small detail that tells a big story about the town.

That plaque marks the building as a cornerstone of local history. Not many ice cream stops can claim a spot on an official walking tour.

You can easily turn your visit into a mini adventure. Follow the walking tour around town, then reward yourself with a scoop at this stop.

Kids might roll their eyes at a history tour at first. Promise them ice cream along the route, and suddenly everyone’s a history fan.

Take a second to read the plaque before you order. It adds a little meaning to an otherwise simple treat, and that’s a pretty cool trade.

Small towns in Colorado often keep their stories alive through places like this. A sweet shop serving people since 1953 is exactly the kind of landmark worth celebrating.

Snap a photo with your cone and the plaque together for the perfect souvenir shot.

Mark Your Calendar Because The Window Closes For Winter

Mark Your Calendar Because The Window Closes For Winter
© Ceaira’s Sweet Shop

Timing is everything with this one. The shop runs as a seasonal business, so it isn’t open all year long.

Seasonal hours are common in mountain towns. Snow and cold weather tend to slow down the cone business quite a bit.

So plan your trip for the warmer months. Late spring and summer are when Ceaira’s Sweet Shop is ready to serve.

A smart move is to check the shop’s latest updates before you head out. Hours can shift a little, especially near the start and end of the season.

I honestly like that it only opens part of the year. It makes the first cone of the season feel like a real event in Colorado, almost like a holiday.

Seventy-three years of sweet treats is worth celebrating. When those windows open again, a little piece of Grand Lake history comes back to life.

Be there for it, and maybe order the huckleberry for old times’ sake.