Someone in New Jersey decided a cannoli needed a cookie upgrade. So they took two pignoli cookies, sandwiched cannoli cream between them, and called it a day.
I’d like to shake that person’s hand. After washing the powdered sugar off mine.
And the bakeries aren’t stopping there. There’s a place making something called Beach Cake, while another sells Birthday Cake-flavored Italian ice.
A Shore bakery opens at 6:30 AM, presumably because the crumb cake crowd doesn’t believe in sleeping in.
You’ll find plenty of old favorites, too, from rainbow cookies to sfogliatelle, with French and Italian baking traditions sharing the spotlight.
Whoever invented that pignoli cannoli sandwich has created a problem: how do you go back to eating the cookies separately?
1. Lyndhurst Pastry Shop

Cookie sandwiches stuffed with cannoli cream sound like a dare. At this family-run bakery, they are simply part of the lineup.
Lyndhurst Pastry Shop pairs pignoli cookies with that sweet ricotta filling. You get chewy almond cookie on both sides and creamy cannoli in the middle.
The regular cookie case gives you plenty more to grab. Mixed Italian biscotti, black and white cookies, and mixed rainbow cookies all show up on the menu.
Pastry fans can go for a California fruit tart or a classic cannoli. You can also find muffins for the morning crowd.
Here is a fun twist for a bakery. The shop also makes Italian ices in creative flavors, including Birthday Cake.
Around Easter season, keep an eye out for pastiera di grano. That Italian wheat pie is a true old-school holiday treat.
Plan to take your goodies to go. The shop offers takeout, pickup, and delivery, but it does not have dine-in seating.
Early birds are in luck, since doors open at 7 AM daily. Closing times vary by season, so check the bakery’s current hours before planning an evening dessert run.
Want to skip a crowd? Weekday mornings tend to be the quietest, while Sunday afternoons get busy.
Coffee is available too, so you can grab a cup with your box. There is also a free parking lot, which makes a quick stop easy.
Address: 256 Ridge Rd, Lyndhurst, NJ 07071
2. The Baker’s Grove

Potato in a pastry puff? Yes, and it sits right next to a Granny Smith apple version for the sweet tooth.
The Baker’s Grove is a local bakery known for fresh, homemade goods. Croissants, cookies, and seasonal pastries are the heart of the menu.
Chocolate lovers should look for the chocolate croissant. If you lean savory, the ham and cheese croissant makes a solid breakfast.
The cookie case brings its own fun. Salted chocolate chip cookies are a highlight, and cinnamon buns are worth a look too.
Dessert people are not left out here. The menu also includes tiramisu and vanilla cake.
Holiday planning gets easier with this spot. The bakery takes orders for Christmas cookie trays, so you can show up to a party looking like a hero.
The space feels modern yet homey, and there is outdoor seating. That means you can nibble a pastry outside on a nice day.
Timing matters with this one. Mondays run only from 9 AM to 1 PM, while Tuesday through Saturday stretch from 7 AM to 5 PM.
Sundays close at 2 PM, so do not count on a late afternoon cookie fix. Saturday mornings tend to be busy, so arrive early for the best pick.
Coffee is on hand to pair with your croissant. Parking is easy too, thanks to a free lot.
Address: 524 Broad St, Shrewsbury, NJ 07702
3. Rispoli Pastry Shop

Old-school bakeries are like grandparents. They do not chase trends, and they somehow always have the good cookies.
Rispoli Pastry Shop fits that description nicely. It is a quaint Italian bakery making classic pastries, cookies, and cakes.
Pignoli cookies are a big reason to stop by. Those pine nut topped almond cookies are a New Jersey holiday favorite for good reason.
Lobster tails are another star here. The flaky, shell-shaped pastries are made on-site, along with cannoli and eclairs.
Need something for a party? A tiramisu cake is on the menu, and so is a chocolate mousse bar.
The selection covers plenty of traditional Italian desserts. You will likely spend a few minutes just staring at the case.
Plan your trip around the schedule. The shop is closed on Mondays and opens at 8 AM Tuesday through Sunday.
Sunday hours end at 2 PM, and that day gets busy in the afternoon. Weekdays tend to be calmer if you like to browse slowly.
You can grab a coffee while you are there. Just know there is no restroom, so this works best as a quick visit.
Parking is simple, with a free lot and free street parking. Delivery is also an option if you cannot make the drive.
Address: 23 Emerson Plaza E, Emerson, NJ 07630
4. Sorrento Bakery

Half bakery, half deli, and fully ready for your lunch break. You can walk out with a chicken cutlet sandwich and a box of cookies in one trip.
Sorrento Bakery is a longtime Italian spot serving pastries, desserts, and sandwiches. The deli counter makes this a rare bakery that can actually feed you a meal.
On the sweet side, cannoli lead the charge. Large eclairs, cupcakes, carrot cake, and strawberry shortcake are also on the menu.
Cookie fans get a serious lineup. Pignoli cookies and macaroons stand out, and lobster tails and tarts are in the mix too.
Fresh bread is part of the package here. So are holiday pies and birthday cakes for bigger moments.
Hours work for early risers and late snackers. The bakery opens at 7 AM daily and closes at 7 PM Monday through Saturday.
Sunday closes a bit earlier at 6 PM. Sunday mornings and Saturday mornings get busy, so plan ahead.
Evenings during the week tend to be quieter. That is a smart time to grab a dessert after work.
Breakfast is also part of the offering, which makes it a fun morning stop. There is a free parking lot as well.
Takeout is the main way to go, since delivery is not offered. Bring a sturdy bag, because you will probably buy more than planned.
Address: 36 Eagle Rock Ave, East Hanover, NJ 07936
5. Bijoux French Pastry

A flourless chocolate cookie might be the most French way to be gluten-free. At this patisserie, it sits on the menu like a quiet little celebrity.
Bijoux French Pastry is an authentic French bakery focused on artisanal pastries and elegant cakes. Montclair already has a lively downtown, and this shop adds a Parisian touch.
Macarons rotate with the seasons, so flavors change through the year. Gluten-free chocolate macarons are also available.
The cookie case goes beyond the flourless option. Double chocolate chip and macadamia cookies are both worth a try.
Morning pastry people, take note. Almond croissants and chocolate pain au chocolat are on the menu.
For something fancy, look at the individual Exotique cake. Canneles and opera gateau also show up here.
Around the holidays, seasonal pies join the lineup. That makes this a handy stop for a dessert table.
Late hours are a bonus. Fridays and Saturdays run until 9 PM, so dessert after dinner is easy.
You can dine in with coffee or mint tea. Takeout, pickup, and delivery are options too.
Parking is on paid streets, so keep that in mind. Weekday mornings tend to be calmer than weekend afternoons.
Address: 17 Church St, Montclair, NJ 07042
6. Deluxe Italian Bakery Inc.

Award winning is a big claim for a donut. Yet the Award Winning Deluxe Bakery Donut sits proudly on the menu here.
Deluxe Italian Bakery Inc. is a long-standing, family-owned bakeshop in South Jersey. Specialty breads, desserts, and pastries fill the shelves.
The Italian cookie selection is a strong reason to visit. Rainbow cookies and pizzelles are part of the traditional lineup.
There is a nice surprise as well. Chrusciki, the crisp, sugar-dusted Polish favorite, can show up here too.
Cannoli, cupcakes, and cheesecake round out the dessert options. Cakes are a big deal, including the 7 Specialty Cake.
Hungry for something savory? The bakery also makes pizza, stromboli, and small hot sandwiches.
The schedule is wonderfully simple. It is open daily from 7 AM to 7 PM, so you never have to guess.
Weekend mornings and Friday mornings get busy. Sunday evening and Monday morning are calmer.
Coffee is available for your donut pairing. There is free Wi-Fi and a restroom, which is not always the case at bakeries.
Dine-in is not offered, so plan on takeout. Delivery and pickup work too, and a free lot makes parking easy.
Address: 680 E Clements Bridge Rd, Runnemede, NJ 08078
7. Palazzone 1960

Route 23 is not the first place you would expect to find a slice of Italy. Still, that is exactly where this family-owned cafe sets its table.
Palazzone 1960 serves Italian pastries, cookies, and gelato alongside a full savory menu. It feels like a European cafe dropped into North Jersey.
Sfogliatelle are a must for pastry fans. The large version is on the menu, and the lobster tail pastry is a fan pick too.
Cookies come in a wide variety. Pignoli cookies are among them, and you can build a box to take home.
Thirsty for something sweet? Italian hot chocolate is thick, rich, and served in different sizes.
Lunch is on offer Tuesday through Sunday. Think antipasto, panini, salads, gnocchi al pesto, and spaghetti al pomodoro.
That makes this a nice spot for a full meal with dessert after. Dine-in is available, and free Wi-Fi is too.
Plan around the hours. The cafe is closed Mondays and open 8 AM to 7 PM the rest of the week.
Weekend afternoons get busy. Tuesday evenings tend to be the quietest time.
Parking includes a free lot and free street spots. Takeout and delivery are both options.
Address: 190 NJ-23, Wayne, NJ 07470
8. Bovella’s Pastry Shoppe

Ever seen a cake made to taste like rainbow cookies? This shop has made one, and it is exactly as fun as it sounds.
Bovella’s Pastry Shoppe is a long-standing mom-and-pop bakery in downtown Westfield. It offers gourmet kosher pastries, treats, and desserts.
Rainbow cookies are a big draw here. They also inspire special cakes for weddings and other celebrations.
Pastry fans have plenty to explore. Lobster tails, apple turnovers, and Nutella cigar pastries all make an appearance.
Cannoli are a classic choice. Croissants and coffee crumb cake work well for breakfast.
Need something showy for a party? Oreo mousse bombs and tiramisu squares make dessert tables look great.
Mixed pastries are another option for gatherings. You get a little bit of many flavors without choosing one.
Hours are generous. The shop opens at 8 AM daily and stays open until 8 PM on Fridays and Saturdays.
Friday evening is the busiest time. Weekday mornings tend to be calm if you like a relaxed visit.
Iced coffee and hot coffee are both available. Free Wi-Fi and free street parking help too.
Address: 101 E Broad St, Westfield, NJ 07090
9. Mueller’s Bakery

Crumb cake at the Jersey Shore is serious business. This old-fashioned bakery is famous for it, and the crumb squares draw a loyal following.
Mueller’s Bakery is a longtime Shore fixture. A morning pastry run here is something of a local tradition.
Doors open at 6:30 AM, which is great for beach days. Get there early, because weekend mornings get busy.
The cookie lineup has some fun local flavor. Go Bay Head Cookies are on the menu, along with linzer tarts and sprinkle cookies.
Danish fans have plenty to pick from. Turnovers, apple pockets, and jelly donuts also show up.
Apple strudel is another favorite. So are blueberry crumb cake and blueberry pound cake.
Cakes get playful here. Beach Cake and Sunflower Cake are both on the menu.
Look for St. Joseph’s pastry when it is in season. Assorted cake slices are handy if you want a little of everything.
The bakery is closed on Mondays. Sunday hours end at 4 PM, while Friday and Saturday run until 6 PM.
There is no dine-in, so plan on takeout. Curbside pickup and several parking options make it easier.
Address: 80 Bridge Ave, Bay Head, NJ 08742
10. Conca D’Oro Italian Pastry Shop

Cookie trays are basically the official party currency of New Jersey. This shop prints plenty of them.
Conca D’Oro Italian Pastry Shop is a traditional, family-run bakery. It specializes in authentic cannoli and a large selection of Italian cookies.
Pignoli cookies are part of that lineup. You can build a tray with a wide mix of homemade favorites.
Hosting a crowd? Full platters of mini Italian pastries are a popular choice for gatherings.
Cannoli are a signature item here. They make a smart add-on to any cookie order.
Big moments are covered too. The shop makes elegant wedding cakes for couples planning a sweet celebration.
Coffee is available if you want a quick treat. The shop also offers in-store shopping and pickup.
Watch the hours before you head out. It is closed Mondays and opens at 9:30 AM Tuesday through Friday.
Saturdays open at 9 AM and close at 6:30 PM. Sundays wrap up early at 2:30 PM, so do not wait too long.
Free parking is available in a lot and on the street. Delivery is offered as well, if you would rather stay home with your tray.
Address: 1039 Stuyvesant Ave., Union, NJ 07083