TRAVELMAG

These 8 Michigan Islands Offer Beautiful Places To Stay Overnight

Derek Lawson 10 min read
Most beautiful Michigan island stays
These 8 Michigan Islands Offer Beautiful Places To Stay Overnight

On one Michigan island, a hotel porch stretches 660 feet. That’s longer than two football fields, and it’s lined with rocking chairs.

The same island doesn’t allow personal cars. You get around by bike, by horse-drawn carriage, or on your own two feet. I love that the loudest traffic sound might be hooves.

Other islands on this list feel even wilder. One is a certified Dark Sky Sanctuary. Another has solar-powered cabins with no running water, plus a steep hike from the dock with wheelbarrows waiting to help.

Some spots come with fancy dining rooms. Others come with freighters sliding past your campfire. I can’t decide which sounds better, and maybe that’s the fun part. Which kind of island night is calling your name?

8. Isle Royale National Park

Isle Royale National Park
© Isle Royale National Park

Michigan’s only national park sits way out in Lake Superior, and you can’t drive there. You’ll reach it by ferry from Houghton or Grand Portage, Minnesota.

That trip alone makes the night feel earned. Once you land, you’ve got a few ways to sleep under a roof.

Rock Harbor Lodge offers lodge-style rooms with lakeside views. Want more space? Housekeeping cabins on Tobin Harbor sleep up to six people.

Each of those cabins has a private bathroom and a kitchenette. That means you can cook breakfast in your socks after a long day on the trail.

Over on the island’s southwest end, Windigo Camper Cabins sit at Washington Harbor. They’re a rustic step up from pitching a tent.

Hungry hikers aren’t left out at Rock Harbor. The Lighthouse Restaurant and Greenstone Grill serve breakfast, lunch, and dinner.

Greenstone Grill keeps it simple with pizza, burgers, sandwiches, and fresh salads. After hiking, simple tastes amazing.

Rock Harbor also has a marina, a camper store, showers, and a gift shop. Forgot something? The store might save your trip.

The real star is the wilderness. Isle Royale is known for backpacking, hiking, and paddling.

You can rent boats, kayaks, and canoes right at Rock Harbor. Fishing charters and sightseeing tours are also on the menu.

Plan around the calendar, though. Lodging here runs seasonally, usually from June through September.

Book early and pack layers. Lake Superior keeps its own schedule, and you’re just a guest.

Address: Rock Harbor, Isle Royale National Park, MI 49931

7. Mackinac Island

Mackinac Island
© Mackinac Island

Horses outrank cars here, and nobody seems to mind. Personal automobiles are banned, so you’ll get around by carriage, bike, or foot.

That one rule changes the whole mood. Your morning commute might be a pedal past the water.

For a big splurge, Grand Hotel is hard to beat. Its front porch stretches 660 feet and claims the title of world’s longest.

Bring a book and grab a seat. You could people-watch for hours and still not reach the end.

Island House Hotel on Main Street offers a different flavor. Its front porch faces the water and comes with rocking chairs.

Fire pits on the lawn make evenings easy. Toasting your toes while the sun sets over the lake? Yes, please.

History runs deep on this island. It was once America’s second national park, and many buildings trace back to the 1800s.

Fort Mackinac lets you poke around that past. The island also has more than 70 miles of trails to explore.

Then there’s the fudge. It’s famous for a reason, and you’ll smell it before you see it.

Timing matters here. Many businesses run seasonally and close for winter.

Summer weekends and events fill up fast. The Lilac Festival in early summer is a crowd favorite, so book ahead.

Pack comfy shoes and maybe a sweet tooth. You’ll need both.

Address: 286 Grand Ave, Mackinac Island, MI 49757

6. Beaver Island

Beaver Island
© Beaver Island

Thirty-two miles of open water separate this island from the mainland. That makes it the most remote inhabited island in the Great Lakes.

People call it America’s Emerald Isle. Once you see the green woods and quiet shoreline, the nickname clicks.

Night is where Beaver Island really shows off. It’s been named a Dark Sky Sanctuary, so the stars get serious.

Lie on a beach blanket and look up. Your phone flashlight will feel almost rude.

For a bed, Emerald Island Inn offers efficiency rooms and suites. The island also has motels and vacation rentals.

Good news for off-season fans, too. Lodging is available year-round here.

Winter visitors can try cross-country skiing, snowshoeing, and snowmobiling. Summer brings hiking, biking, kayaking, swimming, and fishing.

Paddlers can follow the Beaver Island Water Trail. Hikers will find plenty of trails at the George and Althea Petritz Nature Preserve.

Now for the wild history. In 1850, James Jesse Strang built a print shop here after declaring himself king.

Yes, a king, on a Michigan island. That building is now the Old Mormon Print Shop Museum.

Lighthouse lovers get two treats. Beaver Head Lighthouse was decommissioned in 1962 but welcomes visitors in summer.

The Beaver Island Lighthouse adds another stop. Bring a camera and a curious brain.

Address: Emerald Island Inn, Beaver Island, MI 49782

5. Drummond Island

Drummond Island
© Drummond

Got a golf bag and a dirt bike? Drummond Island might be the rare place that welcomes both.

Folks call it the Gem of the Huron. It’s also one of the largest freshwater islands in the United States.

Drummond Island Resort sits on the north shore. You can choose lodge-style rooms or cabins.

Golfers, listen up. The resort’s course, called The Rock, is an 18-hole championship layout designed by Harry Bowers.

That name fits the rugged island setting. Just try not to lose too many balls in the woods.

Food is close by, so you won’t need to wander. Pins Bar and Grill serves pizza, burgers, and sandwiches.

Bayside Dining shifts its menu with the seasons. It’s a nice option when you want something a little different.

Engines more your style? The island has Michigan’s largest closed-loop off-road trail system.

Turtle Ridge ORV Park is part of the fun. There are over 60 miles of ATV routes and 40 miles of ORV routes.

That’s a lot of mud to bring home. Maybe pack an extra pair of jeans.

Big wooded areas cover much of the island. Hikers and nature fans have plenty of room to roam.

Better still, lodging stays open year-round. Fall color trips and snowy getaways are both on the table.

Address: 33494 S Travelers Trail, Drummond Island, MI 49726

4. Bois Blanc Island

Bois Blanc Island
© Bois Blanc Island

Don’t go hunting for a big resort lobby here. Bois Blanc Island keeps things low-key with cabins, cottages, and houses for rent.

That’s kind of the point. You get your own little patch of island life.

Getting there means a ferry ride from Cheboygan. The crossing helps you leave busy days behind.

Many rentals come with lakefront views. Some even include private beach access, which beats sharing your sandcastle.

Here’s a fun bonus. Some properties offer sunset views of the Mackinac Bridge.

Watching that famous span glow at dusk sounds pretty great. You’ll want a chair facing west.

The island works well for slow days. Hiking and biking are popular ways to explore the scenery.

Waterfront wandering is another easy plan. Pick a direction and see what turns up.

History buffs have options too. Local museums and churches give you a peek at island life over the years.

The historic Bois Blanc Island Lighthouse also calls this place home. Lighthouses and Michigan go together like peanut butter and jelly.

Since stays are mostly private rentals, plan ahead. Seasonal availability can vary from place to place.

Bring groceries and good snacks. A quiet island is no fun on an empty stomach.

This is a spot for people who like peace more than packed schedules. Leave the to-do list on the mainland.

Address: Bois Blanc Island, MI 49775

3. Sugar Island

Sugar Island
© Sugar Island

Freighter fans, this island might ruin regular vacations for you. Many rentals look right out at the St. Marys River.

Huge ships pass by while you sip morning coffee. It’s like a parade that never needs tickets.

Sugar Island sits near Sault Ste. Marie. A free car ferry carries you across.

It’s also Michigan’s northeastern-most point. That’s a fun fact to drop at dinner.

Lodging leans toward vacation homes, cottages, and cabins. Plenty of them sit right on the water.

Amenities depend on where you book. Some places offer pontoon boats, private docks, hot tubs, or fireplaces.

Picture yourself on a dock as a freighter glides past. Okay, that was close to a cliche, but it’s true.

The Soo Locks are nearby too. Some rentals even offer views of the locks themselves.

Outdoors lovers won’t get bored. Hiking trails and scenic waterfronts give you room to explore.

Nature fans should check out the Chase Osborn Preserve. It covers more than 4,000 acres.

Beaches here tend to be uncrowded. You might have a stretch of sand mostly to yourself.

Fishing is a big draw on the river. Duck hunting is popular during the season too.

Bring binoculars for ship-spotting. You’ll be surprised how fast you start naming them.

Address: Sugar Island, Sault Ste. Marie, MI 49783

2. Neebish Island

Neebish Island
© Neebish Island

Back in 1889, a keeper’s house went up on this quiet island. Today, that same property lets you camp beside its beach.

The Neebish Island Light Station later served the U.S. Coast Guard until the 1970s. Now it hosts rustic tent and RV sites.

The grounds cover about one acre. You get direct access to a private sandy beach.

Here’s the best part. A wood-fired sauna sits near the shoreline.

Sweat it out, then cool off in the river. That’s a Upper Peninsula spa day.

Evenings center around a large communal fire pit. Swapping stories with fellow campers comes easy there.

Facilities are basic, with porta-potties on site. Oddly enough, there’s guest Wi-Fi too.

Prefer walls and a roof? Vacation rentals like houses, cabins, and cottages are available across the island.

Many come with waterfront views of freighters on the St. Marys River. Those big ships never get old.

Getting there takes a car ferry from Barbeau. The ride is short, but the island feels far away.

Neebish is remote and peaceful. Starry skies are a big part of its charm.

Daytime brings swimming, kayaking, and canoeing. Sunbathing counts as an activity too, right?

Woodsy trails and dirt or gravel roads invite exploring. You can bike them or bring motor sports gear.

Address: Neebish Island Light Station, Neebish Island, Barbeau, MI 49710

1. Lime Island

Lime Island
© Lime Island

No ferry, no cars, and no running water in the cabins. If that sounds like an adventure, Lime Island is ready.

Officially, it’s Lime Island State Recreation Area, run by the Michigan DNR. You’ll need a private boat or charter to reach it.

Mainland parking is in Raber. Skip the canoe, though, since heavy freighter traffic makes small paddle craft a bad idea.

Once you dock, the climb begins. A steep hike leads up to the camping areas.

Wheelbarrows wait to help haul your gear. Pack smart, or your arms will remind you.

The cabins run on solar power. They come in two- and three-bedroom styles and sleep up to eight.

They’re dry cabins, so there are no bathrooms or kitchens inside. Portable toilets and a hand pump for well water handle the basics.

Tent sites are available too. Some sit on wooden platforms, and each site has a fire ring.

About 7 miles of hiking trails wind around the island. Keep an eye out for bald eagles, osprey, and black bears.

Anglers chase walleye, northern pike, herring, and yellow perch. Freighters also pass surprisingly close.

The island once served as a refueling stop for those ships. Old lime kiln ruins still hint at that busy past.

It’s open from Memorial Day weekend through mid-September. Bring patience, and this rugged gem pays you back.

Address: Lime Island State Recreation Area, Lime Island, MI 49736