TRAVELMAG

This New Mexico Deep-Dish Pizza Spot Has People Talking About Its Chicago-Style Pies

Cassie Holloway 10 min read
This New Mexico Deep-Dish Pizza Spot Has People Talking About Its Chicago-Style Pies

The sauce goes on top. The cheese hides on the bottom, and the toppings sit in the middle like a delicious secret.

Not exactly your everyday pizza!

That upside-down build is the signature move at a veteran-owned pizza shop in New Mexico. The deep-dish pies stand about an inch and a half thick.

I think that alone explains why folks reach for a knife and fork.

The room adds its own surprises. Chicago skyline photos and Bulls and Bears memorabilia fill the walls.

And then there are the knights in shining armor standing guard in the corners, which I find wonderfully random.

I like how the place mixes big-city pizza pride with real heart. A POW-MIA table honors prisoners of war and service members missing in action, and the owners are disabled veterans themselves.

Even the menu gets a New Mexico twist, with green chile finding its way onto a Chicago-style pie.

The Pie That Flips Pizza Rules Upside Down

The Pie That Flips Pizza Rules Upside Down
© Chicago Pizza Kitchen

Most pizzas put sauce beneath the cheese. Chicago Pizza Kitchen flips that order for its True Chicago deep-dish pies.

Cheese goes down first, right against the crust. Toppings come next, and a hearty marinara gets smothered across the top.

The finished pie stands about an inch and a half thick. That’s not a slice you fold in half and eat while walking to the car.

There’s a smart reason behind the layering, too. A deep pie bakes longer, and sauce on top helps protect the cheese underneath.

You can order the True Chicago style in small, medium, and large sizes. The extra-large 16-inch option is a pan pizza instead.

The small makes sense if you’re dining solo or just testing the waters. Larger sizes work better for families or anyone feeding a hungry crowd.

Plan on grabbing a knife and fork. This style eats more like a hearty casserole than a floppy slice, and that’s part of the fun.

If you’ve never tried Chicago deep dish, this is a fine place to start. Go in curious, and let the sauce-on-top thing win you over.

Dough That Gets Made Before You Even Wake Up

Dough That Gets Made Before You Even Wake Up
© Chicago Pizza Kitchen

Fresh dough is a daily habit here. The kitchen makes it on the premises every single day.

That matters more than it sounds. Dough is the foundation of any pizza, and deep dish leans on its crust harder than most styles.

Every pizza at Chicago Pizza Kitchen is handcrafted. Nobody is pulling frozen discs out of a box and calling it a day.

The restaurant also highlights locally sourced and all-natural ingredients. That’s a nice touch for a place built around a recipe from far away.

Think about it like a New Mexico twist on a Chicago classic. The style comes from the Windy City, while some of the ingredients come from closer to home.

Handmade pizza does take a little time to bake properly. A thick pie needs the oven to do its full job, so patience pays off.

Calling ahead or ordering online can help if you’re short on time. Then you can swing by and grab your pie when it’s ready.

Either way, you’re getting pizza made with fresh dough prepared on-site. In a fast-food world, that feels refreshingly old school.

Not a Deep-Dish Person? The Menu Has Your Back

Not a Deep-Dish Person? The Menu Has Your Back
© Chicago Pizza Kitchen

Good news for the thin-crust crowd. Deep dish gets top billing, but it isn’t the only choice on the board.

Chicago Pizza Kitchen also offers pan, thin, and gluten-free crusts. That makes it easier to please a group with very different opinions.

You can build your own pizza from the ground up. Pick a crust, choose your toppings, and make it exactly how you like.

Prefer someone else to do the thinking? The specialty pies give you ready-made combos without the decision fatigue.

The gluten-free crust is a helpful option for guests who need it. Families with mixed diets will appreciate not having to split up for dinner.

Here’s a fun strategy for first-timers. Order one True Chicago deep dish and one thin crust, then compare them side by side.

It turns dinner into a friendly taste test. Someone at the table will declare a winner, and someone else will argue about it.

The extra-large pan pizza measures 16 inches. That’s a solid pick for a party, a movie night, or a crew of teenagers with bottomless stomachs.

An Italian Beef Sandwich Worth the Detour

An Italian Beef Sandwich Worth the Detour
© Chicago Pizza Kitchen

Chicago has more than one famous food. The Italian beef sandwich is a hometown legend, and it shows up on the menu here.

Chicago Pizza Kitchen serves the classic Italian beef alongside a meatball sandwich. A Philly cheesesteak and a combo sandwich round out the lineup.

That’s handy when not everyone at the table wants pizza. Maybe your friend is a sandwich loyalist, and that’s okay.

Calzones are another solid pick. They’re basically pizza folded into a pocket, which makes them easy to share or save for later.

The pasta section brings even more comfort food. You’ll find lasagna, spaghetti, and ravioli on the menu.

For starters, breadsticks and garlic bread are ready to warm up the table. Fresh garden salads offer something lighter before the heavy hitters arrive.

A smart move for groups is mixing and matching. Grab a deep-dish pie, add an Italian beef, and pass things around.

That way everyone samples a little Chicago. It’s like a tiny food tour without the airplane ticket.

Knights in Armor Are Guarding Your Pizza

Knights in Armor Are Guarding Your Pizza
© Chicago Pizza Kitchen

One table in the dining room stays set for someone who isn’t there. Chicago Pizza Kitchen keeps a dedicated POW-MIA table as a tribute to prisoners of war and service members missing in action.

It’s a meaningful detail in a casual pizza place. The table honors those who endured captivity or remain unaccounted for.

The tribute carries extra weight because of who runs the business. The owners are disabled veterans, and the restaurant grew from their perseverance.

Knowing that changes how a simple pizza night feels. You’re supporting a local business built by people who served their country.

It’s a good moment to talk with kids about service and sacrifice. A dinner outing can turn into a small lesson about gratitude.

Take a quiet look at the table if you visit. Explaining its meaning only takes a minute, and it sticks with young listeners.

The veteran-owned story also explains the strong sense of pride here. This is a place with roots deeper than its crust.

Pizza and patriotism might seem like an odd pair. Here in New Mexico, they share a dining room just fine.

A Quiet Table With a Powerful Purpose

A Quiet Table With a Powerful Purpose
© Chicago Pizza Kitchen

One table in the dining room stays set for someone who isn’t there. Chicago Pizza Kitchen keeps a dedicated POW-MIA table as a tribute to military veterans.

It’s a meaningful detail in a casual pizza place. The table honors service members who were held as prisoners or never came home.

The tribute carries extra weight because of who runs the business. The owners are disabled veterans, and the restaurant grew from their perseverance.

Knowing that changes how a simple pizza night feels. You’re supporting a local business built by people who served their country.

It’s a good moment to talk with kids about service and sacrifice. A dinner outing can turn into a small lesson about gratitude.

Take a quiet look at the table if you visit. Explaining its meaning only takes a minute, and it sticks with young listeners.

The veteran-owned story also explains the strong sense of pride here. This is a place with roots deeper than its crust.

Pizza and patriotism might seem like an odd pair. Here in New Mexico, they share a dining room just fine.

Save Some Room for Key Lime Pie

Save Some Room for Key Lime Pie
© Chicago Pizza Kitchen

Deep dish is filling, no question about it. Still, dessert here deserves a little planning.

Chicago Pizza Kitchen offers cheesecake and key lime pie. Both make a smooth, cool finish after a hot, saucy pizza.

Key lime pie brings a bright, tangy flavor. It feels like a fresh breath after all that cheese and marinara.

Cheesecake goes the rich and creamy route instead. Pick based on your mood, or split one of each with a friend.

A smart trick is ordering dessert to go. Then you can enjoy it later when your stomach has had time to recover.

Pizza leftovers are another bonus. A thick deep-dish slice often reheats nicely in an oven, so you get round two tomorrow.

Think of the whole meal as a plan instead of a race. Start with breadsticks, enjoy your pie, then finish sweet.

Nobody will judge you for skipping the salad. Well, maybe your mom will, but that’s between you two.

Dine In, Drive Through, or Stay on the Couch

Dine In, Drive Through, or Stay on the Couch
© Chicago Pizza Kitchen

Flexibility is baked right into the setup. Chicago Pizza Kitchen offers dine-in, takeout, and delivery.

There’s even a drive-through option. Grabbing a deep-dish pie without leaving your car feels a little like magic.

The restaurant sits at 4300 Eubank Blvd NE, Albuquerque, NM 87111. It’s on the city’s Northeast Heights side, making it easy to reach on Eubank.

Parking is available for customers. The building is wheelchair accessible, with restrooms and air conditioning inside.

That air conditioning matters during a hot New Mexico summer. Nobody wants to sweat while eating a pizza that’s already steaming.

Check the hours before heading over. Times can shift, so a quick look online keeps you from arriving to a locked door.

Delivery is perfect for game nights or lazy Sundays. Deep dish holds its heat well, which helps on a trip across town.

Takeout gives you the best of both worlds. You get the fresh pie, then enjoy it in sweatpants at home.

The Original Started Something Bigger

The Original Started Something Bigger
© Chicago Pizza Kitchen

Every success story starts somewhere. For this pizza brand, it started right here on Eubank.

This location is the original Chicago Pizza Kitchen. It laid the groundwork before the business grew beyond one shop.

In summer 2025, a second Albuquerque location opened on Golf Course Road. That’s a big step for a veteran-owned local business.

Growth like that usually means people keep coming back. Restaurants rarely expand when the ovens sit quiet.

Still, the Eubank spot holds a special place in the story. It’s where the knights, the skyline photos, and the POW-MIA table live.

Visiting the original feels a bit like seeing a band’s first venue. The newer place is great, but this is where it all began.

New Mexico has no shortage of green chile pride. Having a true Chicago-style option in Albuquerque gives locals a fun change of pace.

So grab a fork, pick your size, and let the sauce-on-top magic happen. Your next pizza night just found its headquarters.