A table for two here is called the Confessional. Yes, you can whisper your pasta order where people once whispered something very different.
The building went up in 1888 as a Catholic church. Today its stained-glass windows glow over plates of lobster ravioli and chicken marsala.
Upstairs, the old choir loft now seats diners instead of singers.
I like how nobody tried to erase the building’s past. The menu even plays along, with salads filed under the Garden of Eden and desserts under Taste of Heaven.
I can’t imagine a more fitting spot in Colorado to praise a good meatball. Add a rumored ghost story or two, and dinner gets even more interesting.
So who’s ready to grab a seat with the congregation?
Dinner Here Comes With More Than A Century Of Backstory

Long before anyone twirled spaghetti inside, Scileppi’s at The Old Stone Church was a real house of worship. Builders finished the stone structure in 1888, and it became the first St. Francis of Assisi Catholic Church in town.
That parish served the community for more than 70 years. In 1966, the congregation moved to a larger location east of town, and the old church went quiet.
For a while, the building simply sat there, waiting for its next chapter. That chapter arrived in 1975, when it reopened as The Old Stone Church Restaurant.
So the dining tradition here is older than many of the people eating in it. That’s a fun detail to share while you wait for your appetizer.
I love that the building never had to pretend to be something else. Its thick stone walls still tell people exactly where they are.
Knowing this history changes how the meal feels, at least a little. You’re not just grabbing dinner in a cool old room.
You’re adding one more evening to a story that started when horses still outnumbered cars on Colorado roads.
A Long Island Family Brought Their Recipes West

New York accents and Colorado mountains might seem like an odd pair. The Scileppi family made it work after moving here from Long Island in 1995.
Their first Colorado restaurant was SliceWorks, which opened in 2012. It focused on the New York-style pizza they knew from back home.
Then came the big leap. In 2018, brothers Lou and Vinny Scileppi opened Scileppi’s at The Old Stone Church, keeping the building’s long restaurant run alive.
Taking over a beloved historic space is no small job. People in a small town tend to have strong feelings about their landmarks, and this one sits right downtown.
The brothers kept the family name front and center, right down to the appetizers. The original Scileppi Family Meatballs arrive with seasoned ricotta, which feels like a recipe someone’s grandmother would guard closely.
I believe that family touch is a big part of the charm. A restaurant run by relatives usually has opinions about how sauce should taste.
Those opinions show up on the plate. It’s Italian food with modern influences, but the roots clearly trace back to a family kitchen far from the Rockies.
Look Up, Because The Stained Glass Steals The Show

Colored light pouring through old church windows is hard to beat as dinner decor. The original stained-glass windows were preserved, and they remain one of the building’s most loved features.
The outside still shows off its original stone facade too. From the sidewalk, it looks every bit like the 1888 church it once was.
Inside, the pews and altars are gone. Family dining areas fill that space now, so the pews traded hymnals for bread baskets.
Exposed brick runs through the room and keeps the historic mood intact. Nothing about it feels like a theme restaurant trying too hard.
Then there’s the old choir loft. It has been turned into a second-floor seating area, giving diners a view over the room below.
Here’s a practical tip for your visit. The church side can feel a bit dim, so bring patience if you love photographing your food.
The cozy, welcoming feel makes up for it. Grab a seat near a window if you can, and let the glass do the decorating while you focus on the menu.
Book The Confessional If You Have Secrets To Share

Some restaurants have booths. This restaurant offers two Confessional seating options: an intimate table for two and a booth accommodating up to four people.
The Confessional table is perfect for date night or a long talk with your best friend. Whatever you admit in there stays between you and your fettuccine.
Bigger groups get their own clever option upstairs. The Last Supper Table is designed for parties, which makes birthday photos a lot funnier.
I can’t imagine a better spot for a family reunion with a sense of humor. Someone will absolutely try to pose like the famous painting.
These special seats are popular, so planning ahead helps. The restaurant takes reservations, and they’re your best bet for landing one of the themed tables.
Walk-ins are welcome too. You just might end up at a regular table instead, which is still inside a former church, so nobody loses here.
Anniversaries and special nights fit this setup nicely. A private little nook feels more personal than a table in the middle of a busy room.
Just don’t expect anyone to hand out penance. The only thing you’ll owe is a promise to save room for dessert.
Even The Menu Reads Like Scripture

Garden of Eden, Fountain of Zuppe, Old Testament. Those aren’t sermon titles, they’re menu sections.
The team leaned fully into the church theme when they organized the food. Salads live in the Garden of Eden, and soups flow from the Fountain of Zuppe.
Traditional pasta dishes are grouped under the Old Testament. Think gnocchi al fresco, veal parmigiana, and linguine with white clam sauce.
The New Testament covers modern Italian entrees. Steaks and seafood show up there, which makes sense for the newer chapter of the menu.
Desserts close things out under Taste of Heaven. Honestly, that might be the most accurate section name in the whole book.
I like how the theme makes ordering feel playful without getting silly. You still get a serious Italian menu, just with a wink attached.
Kids especially tend to get a kick out of this kind of thing. Reading the menu out loud becomes part of the fun before the food even shows up.
Gluten-free pasta is available for some dishes too. Ask your server which choices work, since not every item can be made that way.
Save Room, Because The Pasta Plates Mean Business

Crab-stuffed jumbo shrimp over linguini with lemon garlic butter sauce. That sentence alone is enough to start planning a road trip.
The seafood options at Scileppi’s at The Old Stone Church go well beyond the basics. Seared salmon, lobster ravioli, and shrimp scampi risotto all make appearances.
Meat lovers aren’t left out. Braised short rib ravioli and pan-seared stuffed chicken breast give heartier eaters plenty to consider.
The lasagna has a reputation for being substantial. Chicken marsala and chicken piccata also rank among the dishes people talk about most here.
Before the entrees, watch for the round rolls. They’re chewy and shaped like cinnamon rolls, made for dipping in olive oil and balsamic vinegar.
Those rolls also work wonders on leftover sauce. Nobody should have to leave good marinara behind on a plate.
Starters deserve attention too. Crispy baked Eggplant Fries come with marinara, and the fried calamari has fans calling it the best in Colorado.
My advice is to share a few plates around the table. Portions run generous, and sampling more dishes beats regretting the one you skipped.
Pizza Lovers Get Their Own Slice Of Purgatory

Only a former church could name its pizza counter Purgatory and get away with it. The SliceWorks Purgatory section offers a more casual way to eat here.
It’s the spot for quick New York-style slices. Both menus offer plenty of choices, but pizza is no longer served in the main church dining room after 4 PM daily.
Classic pepperoni is always a safe bet. The slices are big, and many specialty pies come by the slice so you can sample several.
Feeling adventurous? The Jalapeno Popper slice piles on cream cheese, fresh jalapenos, mozzarella, cheddar, and grape jelly.
Yes, grape jelly on pizza. It sounds wild until you remember that sweet and spicy is a winning combo in plenty of snacks.
This side works well for lunch or a casual bite with kids. You still get the family’s New York roots, just without the fancier setup.
I believe every group needs one person brave enough to order the jelly slice. Let them go first and report back to the rest of the table.
Dessert Comes With A Side Of Spooky Stories

Tiramisu served in a Mason jar feels both cozy and a little playful. It’s one of several sweet endings in the Taste of Heaven lineup.
House-made cannoli are another strong pick. Creme brulee and a colossal cheesecake round out the choices for anyone who likes a big finale.
Splitting dessert is smart after a pasta dinner. Then again, nobody said you had to be smart about cheesecake.
Now for the fun part. The old building is rumored to have spirit activity within its walls.
The restaurant has received plenty of calls from people hoping for a ghostly experience. That’s a lot of interest for a place known mostly for meatballs.
Whether you believe in that stuff is up to you. Either way, it makes a great story to tell over coffee and cannoli.
I like that the rumors add mystery without making the place feel creepy. The room stays warm and welcoming, even with a possible extra guest.
Maybe skip mentioning it to younger kids before bedtime. Or mention it and enjoy the wide-eyed reactions across the table.
A Few Smart Tips Before You Head Downtown

Plenty has changed here in the last couple of years. In January 2024, an exterior wall collapsed during construction to expand the restaurant by 6,000 square feet.
Thankfully, nobody was hurt. The restaurant closed for a while, and the expanded space now pairs the old church with a modern glass side.
That mix gives you two very different moods under one roof. Pick the stained-glass church side for history or the brighter side for a casual meal.
You’ll find it at 210 Third St, Castle Rock, CO 80104. It sits right in the downtown area, an easy stop for travelers heading through Colorado.
Hours generally run from 11 AM until 9 PM most days. Fridays and Saturdays stay open until 10 PM.
Hours can shift, especially after big renovations, so check before you go. Reservations are a good idea if you want a themed table.
Outdoor seating is available when the weather cooperates. Catering is offered too, which is handy for parties.
Honestly, few restaurants pack this much history into one meal. Come for the church and stay for the cannoli.